Bar victim ‘looked like lorry hit him’

David McCardle with girlfriend Paula Cassidy
David McCardle with girlfriend Paula Cassidy
Have your say

A MAN found dying outside a pub was so badly injured it looked as though he could have been hit by a lorry, a murder trial has heard.

A metal beer barrel was allegedly used in the fatal attack on David McCardle, 40, last year.

The scene at the Clubhouse Public Bar in Musselburgh, East Lothian, was described to a jury by former licencee Richard Ross, 57, during the first day of evidence in the trial of two men accused of murder.

Mr Ross described how he found his barman, Steven Lindsay, 29, bleeding and half conscious and duty manager Linda Watters in tears.

Police were beginning to cordon off the pub – which has since changed its name – with crime scene tape.

Mr Ross, formerly a mine rescue reservist, said he tried to use his knowledge of first aid to help another man, Derek 
Robertson, 48.

He then described finding Mr McCardle – known as “Yivil” – in a vennel beside the pub. He was lying in a heap, almost in the recovery position, as Mr Ross pushed his way past a policeman who was standing guard.

“He was in a terrible state. He could have been hit by a lorry for all I knew,” Mr Ross told the High Court in 

He said Mr McCardle was a good friend of his family and someone he had known for years.

The court heard that trouble flared after Ross Tait was told to leave the pub because he was barred.

On trial are Tait, 22, and Ryan Cameron, 25, who deny charges of murder and serious assault on August 12 last year. They claim they were acting in self defence and to protect each other.

They are accused of punching Mr McCardle of South Street, Musselburgh, repeatedly throwing a metal barrel at him, struggling with him and repeatedly striking him with a hammer, the barrel and a brush while holding him on the ground.

They are also accused of assaulting Mr Lindsay with a hammer to the danger of his life, assaulting Calum Wight to his injury by punching him and assaulting Mr Robertson to the danger of his life by hitting him with the barrel and a hammer.

Tait is also accused of shouting and swearing and behaving in a threatening manner in the pub.

The trial continues.