Scientists baffled by number of whale deaths on the coasts of Scotland and Ireland

Scientists are baffled by a wave of whale deaths - which saw more carcasses wash up on the coasts of Scotland and Ireland in the past month than in the previous decade.

Tuesday, 11th September 2018, 5:32 pm
Updated Tuesday, 11th September 2018, 5:35 pm
A decomposing 30ft minke whale Belhaven beach, near Dunbar in East Lothian. Picture: SWNS
A decomposing 30ft minke whale Belhaven beach, near Dunbar in East Lothian. Picture: SWNS

In Scotland alone, 37 carcasses of Cuvier’s beaked whales have been discovered - all in an advanced stage of autolysis, or self-digestion, since the start of August.

And another 14 bodies were discovered on the western seaboard of Ireland, with one found off the coast of Northern Ireland.

The spate of deaths has shocked marine biologists, who analysed data over the past 25 years which suggested an average of 3.2 whales are stranded per year.

Sign up to our daily newsletter

The i newsletter cut through the noise

Cuvier’s beaked whales (Ziphius cavirostris) are native to both British and Irish waters where they occur in deep waters - often more than 50 km offshore.

The species is one of the most sensitive to acoustic disturbance and it has been suggested that military activity involving sonar could be linked to the deaths.

Stranding co-coordinator at the Scottish Marine Animal Strandings Scheme, Nick Davidson, said: “It is unprecedented.

“We don’t have any idea what is happening.

“We probably never will because of the condition of the animals.

“The body conditions is advanced decomposition.

“The state of condition means the tests we can do are limited.

“We can look at the genetics and toxicology and we can check the stomach contents.

“We haven’t found any indication of plastic ingestion - they don’t ingest macroplastics.

“We know they get microplastics from food. The amount of damage they cause is debatable, it’s fairly early science.

“It’s unlikely to cause a massive die-off.”

Nick said the recent wave of deaths is being referred to as an “unusual mortality event”.

He said: “They have died quite some time ago and washed up off the coast.

“These particular species are very susceptible to noise, particularly sonar.

“We know this from cases which have happened elsewhere in the world.

“These animals five about 3km deep to hunt for food, then they come up very slowly.

“If they are exposed to loud noise, it disrupts the animal and they go up too quickly - it’s like decompression sickness.

“Unfortunately the animals which have been found are in such a condition that the finger can’t be pointed at anybody.”

Read More

Read More
The best places to see whales in Scotland

Scientists will be trying to establish whether the animals came from one particular location, and died at the same time.

Writing on Facebook, a spokesman for the Scottish Marine Animal Strandings Scheme said: “Analysis of 25 years of stranding data indicates a long-term average of 3.2 whales per year, or put another way more animals have stranded in the past four weeks than in all the previous ten years.

“This is obviously really unusual and something we, along with many of our colleagues, are working to investigate.

“All of these carcases stranding in Scotland were in advanced state of autolysis, and had been at sea for many days.

“Consequently, it has not been possible to derive much pathological information from these cases, which is a pain in the rear, as this is information we need to identify possible causes of death.”

The post added: “There are many case studies from the Atlantic and Pacific Oceans and Mediterranean Sea where mass-strandings of this species were linked to exercises using military sonar.

“Beaked whales, like many cetaceans, ‘see’ the world through sound, so excessive underwater noise can have potentially disastrous effects on their physiology and behaviour.

“Loud noise can damage the sensitive hair cells in the ear, rendering the animal functionally deaf, or cause gas bubbles to form in the tissues leading to the equivalent of the bends.”

The organisation is hoping to work with oceanographers who could study wind and tidal patterns and establish where the animals died.