Youth climate strikers will face no punishment by Edinburgh Council amid one-day permission limit
YOUTH climate strikers will only be allowed to demonstrate one day per school year - but will face no punishment for skipping lessons.
Following two separate emergency motions by Green councillors earlier this year, pupils were allowed to attend climate emergency demonstrations with parental permission on a one-off basis. But officials warned that “potential for adverse risk to children who are absent and unsupervised is high and runs counter to child protection and raising attainment.”
The report adds that “almost all headteachers were not in support of children’s absence being authorised” by councillors as it had “devalued the hard work they had undertaken in working with parents who did not value good attendance at school”.
The city council’s education, children and families committee approved a motion by the SNP-Labour coalition to limit authorised absences to one day per school year – despite a plea from activists to back their strike action.
Youth climate activist, Sandy Boyd, Trinity Academy pupil, said the decision would be “morally wrong”.
He added: “The youth climate strike movement has brought change across the world. It will stop this progress dead in its tracks. You are trying to suppress young people’s opinions on matters that will affect young people.
“We are imploring this council to allow us authorised absence to pressure governments – finally, we are seeing some action. The educational value of taking part in these events is massive. It’s building a society that we want to see. We will keep doing them until we see change.”
But council officers highlighted the importance of ensuring pupils attend lessons.
Lorna Sweeney, the council’s schools and lifelong learning senior manager, said: “Fundamentally we have to make sure the children attend. If we give conflicting information to parents it make the whole purpose of education very difficult.
“The principle purpose of schools is to raise attainment. The single biggest factor is attendance.”
Andy Gray, head of schools and lifelong learning, said if pupils take part in strike action with parental permission, there would be no financial penalty.
He added: “We are not going to punish children for this activity but what we are saying is that it’s definitely an unauthorised absence.”
Councillors voted to limit the authorised strike action to one day.
Education, children and families convener, Cllr Ian Perry said: “There’s no doubt if I was at school I would be doing exactly what Sandy is doing. I think everybody recognises that movement is increasing and is having a big affect.
“Having said that, we have to remind people the duty of this education committee to provide the best education for the young people of this city to prepare them for life. We would then be saying that attendance at school is not important and we don’t value it.
“I think in order to show solidarity with the climate movement, we should allow one day.”
Conservative education spokesperson, Cllr Callum Laidlaw, backed the limit.
He said: “There are consequences of missing school and we have a duty of care.
“A strike is not a strike because it’s authorised – it becomes a day off.”
But Green councillors called for the proposals to be halted.
Cllr Steve Burgess said: “To place an arbitrary limit on it at this stage does not appear to be responding appropriately to young people. Let’s keep an open mind and do it on a case by case basis.”
Sign up to our newsletter: enter your email in the box at the top of this article to get daily updates straight to your inbox.