Hospital building work was ‘harming’ babies

The entrance and construction works at the maternity section of St John's Hospital. Picture: Joey Kelly
The entrance and construction works at the maternity section of St John's Hospital. Picture: Joey Kelly
Have your say

HEALTH chiefs have been left with a bill worth tens of thousands of pounds after doctors put a halt to building work that was harming premature babies at a major hospital.

The £1.7 million refurbishment of the birthing unit at 
St John’s Hospital in Livingston has been delayed by almost three months after the project was found to be having “a detrimental impact on wellbeing” of the tiny patients.

Gordon Beurskens. Picture: Ian Georgeson

Gordon Beurskens. Picture: Ian Georgeson

NHS Lothian today came under fire from campaigners, who accused it of failing to plan properly for the renovation, which was taking place adjacent to the Special Care Baby Unit, where some of the region’s most poorly infants are treated.

The health service has been forced to fork out £76,000 to temporarily move the unit, while the opening of the modernised facility, which had been scheduled to be ready by the spring, has been pushed back to June.

One staff member said the vibrations caused by building work were “echoing through the room”, resulting in the babies becoming distressed.

They added: “Noise for pre-term infants causes irritability. Their sleep patterns are very sensitive to external stimulus, which is why when they’re pre-term and in incubators we keep the lights low and the areas as calm as possible. The renovations were disturbing that.

“Noise can cause their oxygen saturation levels to drop as it affects their breathing and also their feeding in particular, which again is all linked to irritability. If the baby is irritable they won’t eat properly, sleep properly and it all has a knock-on effect. I think they hadn’t anticipated the vibrations. The refurbishment had been delayed for some time so when it did get the go-ahead, it was maybe rushed.”

NHS Lothian insisted that it had planned for the impact of noise and carried out testing, but believed adequate measures had been put in place.

However, it has since been admitted that “the reality was that the prolonged nature of the noise had not been able to be tolerated”.

At a meeting of the health board’s finance and resources committee, incubators magnifying the effect and noise of vibration were blamed.

Gordon Beurskens, of the Action to Save St John’s Hospital group, said the episode was another example of NHS Lothian delivering “poor management, unnecessary waste and delayed outcomes”.

He added: “Maybe the £76,000 could have been spent on baby ear protectors to drown out the noise as well as the pathetic excuses from NHS Lothian.”

Frances McGuire, NHS Lothian’s clinical midwifery manager, said: “Noise and vibrations were identified as a possible risk and we carried out tests before work started.

“Despite this testing, the clinical team raised concerns that the noise and vibrations may have an impact on the babies and the work was stopped immediately.

“The special care unit has now been relocated to ensure a quiet, comfortable and safe environment.

“It is unfortunate this has resulted in a delay to the upgrading of the delivery suite but the safety and wellbeing of the babies in our care is always our top priority.”