Family wins £185k payout over son’s death crash

Michael Joyce died in a car crash on the A9. Picture: contributed
Michael Joyce died in a car crash on the A9. Picture: contributed
Have your say

SIX members of a family of an Edinburgh man who died in a road crash have won a £185,000 payout after suing his girlfriend for causing the accident.

Hazel Gibson’s boyfriend Michael Joyce, 31, who lived in the Canongate, and her seven-year-old son Cole Gibson were killed when the Renault Kangoo she was ­driving was involved in a head-on collision.

Ms Gibson, 31, from Lochgelly in Fife, was pregnant at the time of the crash on the A9 in Perthshire in November 2011. She suffered serious injuries and was rushed to hospital with pelvic fractures, broken ribs and a fractured spine.

But the parents of Mr Joyce and other family members launched a legal action against her and her insurers at the Court of Session.

They claimed she had lost control of the vehicle and caused it to swerve into the opposite lane, where it crashed into an oncoming Peugeot 206.

In court, Ms Gibson’s lawyers blamed Mr Joyce for the crash, and claimed he had grabbed the steering wheel, causing the car to veer across the carriageway.

But in a judgment published yesterday, Lord Kinclaven ruled that Ms Gibson had been at fault and awarded damages totalling £185,000 to six relatives of Mr Joyce.

In his judgement he said: “Clearly, this is a tragic case for all concerned. I have given anxious consideration to the evidence and to everything said [on behalf of the defenders and on behalf of the pursuers]. I have reached the conclusion that the pursuers are entitled to reparation from the defenders.

“On the evidence, the defenders have failed to provide an acceptable non-negligent account of how the accident occurred. I was not satisfied by the first defender’s explanation. It follows that the agreed presumption of negligence applies.”

Mr Joyce, who was not Cole’s father, was declared dead by paramedics at the scene.

Mr Joyce’s family claimed Ms Gibson had changed her story several times about the circumstances of the accident.

At one stage she posted a Facebook message saying her partner was a “hero” as he had sacrificed himself to save her and her unborn child.

Accident investigators told the court the accident was likely to have been caused by Ms Gibson initially swerving to the left and then overcorrecting to the right.

Speaking shortly after the ­tragedy, Ms Gibson told how she had taken comfort from the fact Cole’s organs had 
been donated to help other youngsters.

Five months after the crash Ms Gibson gave birth to a son. She said wearing a seat belt had saved both their lives.