‘When did Hearts last play really well?’: Journalists’ predictions for Hearts v St Johnstone

Not a single member of the online team predicted a Dundee victory from midweek. Much like the Hearts team, they’ve had to pick themselves up, dust themselves down and go again.

Friday, 25th January 2019, 12:19 pm
Updated Friday, 25th January 2019, 2:25 pm

Join our Facebook group Our Edinburgh to share images and news from and around the Capital

Patrick McPartlin: After describing Hearts’ performance against Dundee on Wednesday night as “p**h”, Craig Levein will be looking for a reaction from his players against St Johnstone. The return of Steven Naismith will be a big boost, even with Peter Haring still sidelined, but the Perth Saints are no slouches. It’ll be another intriguing game at Tynecastle but possibly one without a clear winner. Prediction: Score draw

Mark Atkinson: It’s becoming clearer and clearer that if Hearts don’t have Naismith in their starting XI, they tend not to win games. His absence was stark on Wednesday in a surprisingly listless defeat by Dundee. He is back for St Johnstone’s visit to Tynecastle and I think that will make a huge difference. Not only does he offer an attacking threat, but he manages the game on the pitch, cajoling and barracking his team-mates. He is Hearts’ talisman. With that in mind, I can’t see Hearts losing a second game on the spin on home turf. St Johnstone are one of the form teams in the league right now, but I have an inkling that Levein will get his players fired up and get a reaction. I don’t think much football will get played and this game is likely to be settled by a single goal, for me most likely to come from a man in maroon.

Sign up to our Hearts newsletter

The i newsletter cut through the noise

Michael Smith shoots for goal during the last meeting at Tynecastle between the two sides. Picture: SNS

Joel Sked: Or should it be Steven Naismith v St Johnstone? Not a lot can be added to what has been said and is being said by fans and pundits alike. It’s as if Hearts are an aimless, emotionless, empty shell until Naismith provides direction, personality and a verve. Yet, it is not straightforward that Hearts will pick up the three points. St Johnstone are having an excellent season under Tommy Wright and are going under the radar somewhat due to other ‘stories’ in the league. They have added Michael O’Halloran to their attacking arsenal and have one of the best young Scottish centre-backs in Jason Kerr. Saints won’t make it easy for Hearts which could lead to a restless and frustrating afternoon at Tynecastle. Draw.

Craig Fowler: When was the last time Hearts played really well? Like, actually put in a performance where you came away saying ‘they were excellent’? Of course, it’s easy to say the derby at Easter Road, but while it was a terrific night for the Hearts fans, and the players handled the intensity of the fixture superbly, it was hardly a commanding showing against a Hibs side who are no great shakes themselves. Even after Naismith’s return Hearts have still been flat for the most part and another display along those lines will result in only one thing on Saturday. St Johnstone have won seven of their ten away games this season and will emerge with all three points unless Hearts can pull out a showing to match those we witnessed back in the summer and autumn months. Prediction: Away win

Anthony Brown: St Johnstone have been in better form than Hearts in recent months and generally look a more convincing outfit at present. Regardless of how things are going, however, there is little logic in predicting a home defeat for a Hearts team set to contain their three most senior players, Christophe Berra, John Souttar and Steven Naismith, for the first time since August. A tight game beckons but the hosts, eager to banish Wednesday’s dismal defeat by Dundee, have enough in their armoury to shade it. Hearts win

Neil McGlade: Levein took a leaf out of Neil Lennon’s book by publicly criticising one of his strikers in wake of the Dundee loss. The hooking of the “rubbish” David Vanecek after 34 minutes has was controversial to say the least – just ask Michael Stewart. It will be interesting to see if Levein starts the Czech man against St Johnstone. On the pitch, Hearts are in desperate need of three points if they are to maintain their push for a European spot, which is becoming increasingly unlikely by the week. The return of Naismith is a welcome boost but Saints are well drilled. Draw.