There are a number of options available to him in the centre of the pitch, Craig Wighton is in form so does he partner Liam Boyce? Will Josh Ginnelly make the game after picking up an injury against Arbroath? And does Steven Naismith and his experience get the nod in the attack?
These are topics fans will have been debating this past week in the build-up to the Edinburgh derby showdown at Hampden Park.
We asked Hearts fans to choose their XI via a poll. Scroll down and click through for the results with at least one surprising omission.
1. GK - Craig Gordon
The undisputed No.1 in the eys of the staff, players and fans. Photo: Ross Parker - SNS Group
2. RB: Michael Smith
There was never going to be another choice. Photo: Ross Parker - SNS Group
3. CB - Craig Halkett
The centre-back has been a key influence under Neilson. Photo: Mark Scates - SNS Group
4. CB - Mihai Popescu
The Romanian centre-back is slowly but surely building a relationship with Halkett. Had his strongest performance at Arbraoth. Photo: Ross Parker - SNS Group