Ex-Hearts man believes Rangers star deserved same punishment as Hibs ace Ryan Porteous

Rangers midfielder John Lundstram deserved the same punishment as Ryan Porteous during Hibs’ 2-1 defeat at Ibrox, according to BBC pundit Michael Stewart.

By Craig Fowler
Tuesday, 5th October 2021, 9:38 am
Updated Tuesday, 5th October 2021, 1:41 pm
John Lundstram (above) has been discussed in the debate over Ryan Porteous' red card at Ibrox. Picture: SNS
John Lundstram (above) has been discussed in the debate over Ryan Porteous' red card at Ibrox. Picture: SNS

The former Hearts captain, who also had a spell at Easter Road, reckons the two challenges were similar enough that referee Nick Walsh should have dealt with them in the same way, though he doesn’t think either deserved red cards.

Porteous was sent packing for a challenge on Joe Aribo during the first half with Hibs leading 1-0. Lundstrum also lunged in on Josh Doig but didn’t receive anything from the official.

Stewart wrote on Twitter: "The Lundstram tackle doesn’t look as bad as Porteous, but if you use the same logic for Porteous to be a red then it applies to Lundstram too. To be clear neither are a red card for me.

Sign up to our Hibs football newsletter

"Porteous is a very talented young player who is continuing to get better, he has a hard streak which needs to keep being channeled and evolve.

"Some of the comments about him are way off mark. He’s at a great club with a top manager who is perfect to keep helping him grow."

Stewart’s take clashes with that of fellow pundit Alex Rae. The former Ibrox midfielder didn’t believe the two tackles were comparable when appearing on Clyde Superscoreboard.

He said: "He clearly lunges towards the ball, but if you are talking about endangering him, I didn't quite see the same as Porteous.

"I don't think it was anywhere near the same force as Porteous, and I don't think it's reckless because he's on that side of the ball.

Message from the editor

Thank you for reading this article. We're more reliant on your support than ever as the shift in consumer habits brought about by Coronavirus impacts our advertisers.If you haven't already, please consider supporting our sports coverage with a digital sports subscription.