The 30-year-old Dundonian served his time assisting coaches like Nuno Espirito Santo and Rafa Benitez. Now he gets to call the shots, negotiate with agents, sign some players and release others. Being Hearts head coach is a privileged position and one he worked long and hard to achieve.
Cathro explained why his character and personality are more suited to making the critical decisions rather than helping someone else do so.
“I genuinely don’t feel any massive difference or that my life has been shook up. The main difference is that, rather than having an opinion or thinking about a lot of things, I’m now making the decisions on all these things,” he said, speaking exclusively to the Evening News.
“I feel that’s really the only difference. Rather than being involved in somebody else’s decision-making, it’s my decision-making.
“That’s easier for me to do. I’m much more comfortable holding the responsibility than trying to help when it’s somebody else’s responsibility. It’s just the way I am. It’s been fine so far.”
Learning about life at Tynecastle has consumed much of his time over the four weeks since he replaced Robbie Neilson. In particular, he had to find out about a largely new group of players. Results like the one at Dens Park two days before Christmas, when Hearts sacrificed a 2-0 lead in a harrowing 3-2 defeat, perversely helped Cathro’s learning process.
“I’m somebody who thinks every single day whether something might have been better if we’d done X instead of Y. That’s a constant thing,” he admitted. “To this point, the things which haven’t gone so well were things we needed to happen in order to know.
“When you’re new into a club with a new set of dynamics, there are little stories that you don’t know. There’s a lot things you need to try and understand quickly. In the early stages, you just don’t know what you don’t know until somebody tells you or it smacks you in the face.
“We’ve probably had to live through those things to learn quickly what the alternatives are. So far, we’ve got to take value from the first period of time – that’s the negatives and the little positives which were there as well. We have to make sure we can be in a more informed position very quickly.”
One win, one draw and three defeats wasn’t the start Cathro hoped for in management. He doesn’t shirk the issue and openly concedes that Hearts should have garnered more points from those fixtures. He is attempting to instil a more controlled style of play based around ball retention and is confident progress is being made, albeit it is results which ultimately matter.
“I think there is some progress,” continued Cathro. “When I look from day zero until now, and look at the small steps we want to take to eventually have a way of playing which will make us stronger and more consistent, then there has been progress in that direction.
“The games are the main thing and my take on that is that we should have five more points than we do. That’s quite a big number across five games and there’s a big disappointment in not achieving that.”
Again, he willingly carries the can.
“I would probably also add that, in this situation, I’m the one who has to put the hands in the sky and accept responsibility for that. I’m comfortable with that. The two results against Partick [1-1 draw] and Dundee should have been different results.”