Why do Edinburgh locals spit on the Heart of Midlothian?

The sight of ordinary men and women launching globules of phlegm at a heart-shaped mosaic of coloured granite setts can often draw looks of bafflement and disgust on the faces of visitors to our fair city.

By David Mclean
Friday, 24th April 2020, 7:30 am

While spitting in public is not advised during a global pandemic, most locals, if asked, will tell you the iconic Heart of Midlothian emblem on the city’s Royal Mile is covered with gob for good luck.

And though this may be the case for many who participate in the tradition – save for some Hibs fans, who may have their own reasons – Edinburghers first spat on the site before the heart mosaic even existed and it had little to do with superstitions.

The mosaic marks the site of the infamous Tolbooth prison, which stood menacingly in the middle of the High Street for more than 400 years.

Sign up to our Retro newsletter

The Heart of Midlothian on the Royal Mile, where it said u should spit upon it if you walk over it to bring luck.

The Old Tolbooth

Dubbed the Heart of Midlothian, as it once marked the administrative centre of the county, the 14th century building was only around three-storeys tall, but cast a shadow to rival nearby St Giles’ Cathedral in the minds of those who passed it daily.

Read More

Read More
Lost Edinburgh: The Old Tolbooth Prison

Countless souls were incarcerated within its walls, many of them condemned and awaiting their fate at one of the town’s execution spots.

The Tolbooth Prison stood for more than 400 years.

While the building was already hated, legend has it the spitting tradition began due to the Porteous riots of 1736, when Captain John Porteous of the City Guard ordered the killing of six rioters. An angry mob later had Porteous tried and imprisoned at the Tolbooth himself.

It is from this point onwards that locals are believed to have spat in disgust at the entrance to the building whenever they passed it.

While architectural traces of the building were all but swept away with its demolition in 1817, the legacy of the Tolbooth survived and so did the tradition.

One man who had a penchant for preserving Edinburgh’s heritage was author Sir Walter Scott, who salvaged the Tolbooth’s sputum-stained main door for his Abbotsford home. The popularity of Scott’s novel, The Heart of Midlothian, a direct reference of the prison and published within 12 months of its demolition, led to the site of the Tolbooth being permanently marked in the shape of a heart. The Tolbooth’s legacy was further secured in 1874, when a group of gents formed a new football team, calling it the Heart of Mid-lothian after their favourite dancehall, which in turn had been named after the hated prison.

Workers replacing the Heart of Midlothian on the Royal Mile in May 1978.

Even the club’s current crest, a spitting image of the Royal Mile mosaic, recognises the link.