Anti-social behaviour in Midlothian is 'out of control' says local MSP Colin Beattie
‘There is clear evidence that youngsters from primary school and above are creating mayhem’ - Colin Beattie MSP
Anti-social behaviour is out of control and has left Dalkeith town centre "almost a no-go zone at night", Midlothian North SNP MSP Colin Beattie has claimed.
In a debate which he sponsored in the Scottish Parliament, Mr Beattie said: "First, I simply state that, in my constituency of Midlothian North, antisocial behaviour is out of control. Over the past three to four years, there has been a steady increase in incidents, much to the distress of my constituents.
.png?crop=3:2,smart&trim=&width=640&quality=65)

“I do not minimise the efforts that the local council and the police have made to manage the situation. However, in my opinion, they simply do not have the tools to do so effectively.
"There is clear evidence that youngsters from primary school and above are creating mayhem. Setting fire to plastic recycling bins is a great favourite, but fighting — mostly between themselves in public — is frequent and causes considerable anxiety among residents.
"Dalkeith town centre is almost a no-go zone at night; youths in dark clothing and balaclavas seem to feature at the centre of the problems."
Mr Beattie highlighted also pointed to anti-social behaviour on public transport. "The level of behaviour on buses is unacceptable, and neither passengers nor bus drivers should have to tolerate the level of misbehaviour and intimidation that a group of youngsters or adults can create.”
He said tackling the problem by taking free bus passes away from offenders would be "a start". But he added: "I suspect that a more robust response will be needed. When dealing with underage youngsters, the police say that they have few options, and no real deterrent unless serious criminal activity is involved."
He said shoplifting had become "a lucrative hobby for some people of all ages". And he said one supermarket had told him it had lost around £25,000 over a six-month period.
"Retailers also complain that nothing can be done — they call the police and no one responds, or the police visit but rarely catch the criminals involved."
He said too often shoplifting was treated as a minor crime and the culprits were rarely sent to prison. "Shoplifters are straight back out on to the streets and offending again. That is not a deterrent, and I know that the police find that very frustrating."
And Mr Beattie continued: "Young people using motorcycles or e-bikes have become both an annoyance and a hazard. The noise is intrusive and disturbing and the damage that is done to public areas is considerable. They cause fear and upset, especially among older residents.
"Antisocial behaviour in schools is increasing, with attacks on teachers and other pupils becoming commonplace. It is all part and parcel of the fundamental shift in our society that urgently needs addressed.
"The police have made it clear to me that legislation around e-bikes is not up to date, which leaves them in a difficult position when they are dealing with situations involving e-bikes. I ask the Scottish Government to consult the police to ensure that legislation is fit for purpose and will support the police in dealing with the issue.
"School curriculums must provide information not only on the rights that young people have but, just as important, on their obligations and responsibilities to society as a whole."
Speaking in the same debate, Edinburgh and Lothians East Green MSP Kate Nevens said there was a need for new ideas and approaches to respond to anti-social behaviour. "We need to properly understand the underlying social and economic causes and consequences of harmful behaviour.”
She said it was a mistake to think anti-social behaviour was caused mostly by young people. Recent statistics showed that two-thirds of those convicted for antisocial behaviour offences were over 30.
"By focusing solely on young people, we risk ignoring root causes and reinforcing harmful cycles of alienation and mistrust between generations, with continuing unhelpful stereotypes of young people having an impact on policy and decision making.
"Our approach is still focused on antisocial behaviour as an individual problem, rather than as an expression of too many parts of our society being left behind, and we should be looking to change that."
Edinburgh and Lothians East Labour MSP Katherine Sangster said anti-social behaviour was raised repeatedly by voters during the election campaign.
"We have all heard deeply concerning stories from our constituents, including those about residents feeling unsafe in their own communities, businesses facing threats and vandalism, and workers being subjected to unacceptable abuse simply for doing their jobs.
"The rise in antisocial behaviour has not happened in isolation. The number of full-time equivalent police officers is now almost 900 lower than it was a decade ago. At the same time, as Police Scotland has been required to make more efficiencies, many communities have seen a reduced visible police presence on their high streets and in their neighbourhoods.
"As we move into the summer months, communities deserve confidence that they will not experience the disruption that we have seen in recent years, including in places such as Portobello beach."
She pointed to an SNP manifesto promise of a trial fund for "social impact partners" and asked when it would be established, how success would be measured and what action would follow from its findings.
Kirsten Oswald, Minister for Victims and Community Safety, said recent legislation included the possibility of removing free bus travel from offenders, the government had made £3 million available in 2026-27 to Police Scotland for tackling retail crime and it was working with the police to address the antisocial use of e-bikes and e-scooters
And she said: “We are committed to providing a £200,000 kick-starter fund to develop proposals for social impact partnerships, focusing on early intervention and justice and beginning with reducing reoffending and creating safe spaces for young people in order to divert them from antisocial behaviour.”