Football captain who left man unconscious after Edinburgh pub brawl spared jail term
Dunfermline Athletic captain Kyle Benedictus has been spared a jail term - after he left a man unconscious and with a broken bone in his neck during a violent pub fight.
The burly centre half left victim Dean Wilkes lying out cold after grabbing the man in a headlock and repeatedly punching him to the head leading to the pair falling to the floor. Mr Wilkes smashed his head off the bottom of the bar where he suffered a broken bone in his neck and later needed surgery.
Benedictus, 34, fled the scene following the incident at Freddy’s Bar in the capital’s city centre but was arrested shortly after and charged with the assault in March last year.
The footballer, of Plean, near Stirling, pleaded guilty to a charge of assault to severe injury when he appeared at Edinburgh Sheriff Court last month and he returned for sentencing on Wednesday.
Solicitor Darryl Lovie, defending, said it was accepted his client had acted under provocation by Mr Wilkes. Mr Lovie said: “It is fair to say the situation that developed at Freddy’s in Edinburgh was not one sought out by Mr Benedictus.


“What is clear is that he was enjoying a night out with a friend and team mate, the former co-accused Mr Fisher. Mr Benedictus became aware Mr Fisher had been assaulted in an unprovoked basis.
“It was his intention to simply remove himself from the premises. Mr Wilkes approached Mr Benedictus and Mr Fisher in what appeared to have been an animated fashion. It is clear that Mr Wilkes was looking for trouble at that point.”
He added: “If it were not for the behaviour of Mr Wilkes this incident would not have happened.”
Mr Lovie said his client had “badly let himself down” and wished to “apologise to the court for his behaviour, his family, his colleagues and the club”.
Sheriff Douglas Keir accepted there had been provocation to the assault and after hearing the mitigation said he could deal with the case by way of a non-custodial sentence. Sheriff Keir said due to Benedictus “previous good character” and “genuine remorse” he was content to impose a community payback order with an unpaid work element of 200 hours.
Previously the court was told Benedictus and Mr Wilkes were at Freddy’s bar separately when members of their groups became involved in an argument on March 2 last year.
Fiscal depute Eilidh Grant said the footballer’s former co-accused Sam Fisher, also a professional footballer, was punched in the face by an unidentified male during the row. Fisher was ushered away by a pub employee but later in the evening was said to have approached the group of males again where “Benedictus stopped him and pulled him back by his clothing”.
Ms Grant said: “Wilkes approached Benedictus and Fisher and made remarks towards them and this resulted in an argument between Fisher and Wilkes. Wilkes continued to provoke Fisher and Benedictus intervened at this point and the accused punched Wilkes to the face.
“The accused then grabbed witness Wilkes placing him in a headlock where he continued to strike Wilkes to the face.”
The court heard the pair fell to the ground during the struggle and Mr Wilkes cracked his head off the bar that resulted in him losing consciousness. The prosecutor said the victim was taken to the city’s Royal Infirmary following the assault but was discharged soon after.
He then had to attend his local GP following day and it was discovered he had suffered a broken bone in his neck that required corrective surgery.
Benedictus pleaded guilty to assaulting Dean Wilkes and did seize him by the head, place him in a headlock and repeatedly strike him on the head causing him to fall to the ground to his severe injury on March 3 this year.
Benedictus is the current captain of Dunfermline Athletic making 86 appearances and scoring eight goals since signing for the East End Park club in 2022. He previously spent seven years playing with Raith Rovers and has also turned out for Alloa Athletic, Dundee and Montrose.
Former co-accused Sam Fisher, 24, also plays for Dunfermline Athletic and is currently on loan at Scottish League One side Kelty Hearts.