Man accused of murdering Edinburgh woman Nicola Stevenson with a claw hammer wanted to be in a relationship with her, court told

A man who is accused of bludgeoning an Edinburgh woman to death with a claw hammer and dumping her body in a wheelie bin wanted to be in a relationship with her, but she ‘hated him’, a court heard.

Richard Canlin is on trial at Hove Crown Court for the murder of Nicola Stevenson

Nicola Stevenson, 39, was found dead in a bin dumped undergrowth on the edge of the recreation ground, Lewes, Sussex, on November 13, last year.

The vulnerable mother-of-two, a former Balerno High School pupil, had been missing from her home for five weeks.

Richard Canlin, 41, who is unemployed and of no fixed address, is standing trial at Hove Crown Court accused of her murder.

Murdered: Nicola Stevenson

The court heard that Nicola had formed a relationship with a man called Nick Thompsett after they had met online.

He would regularly come round to her flatwhere Canlin was lodging and the pair would cuddle up on the sofa.

Giving evidence, Mr Thompsett said Canlin would get annoyed when he saw them together and would give them funny looks.

He said both Nicola and Canlin told him they were brother and sister, but they were not related in any way.

The claw hammer prosecutors say was used to murder Nicola Stevenson

Mr Thompsett told the court that Nicola and Canlin would argue and Nicola was ‘frustrated by him’ and ‘wanted him out’.

She told Mr Thompsett the week before she was found dead that Canlin wanted to be in a relationship with her but she ‘hated him’.

Mr Thompsett told the court that Canlin would get jealous and angry, and he stole Nicola’s medication and her tobacco and had ‘blown his top at her a couple of times’.

He told the court that Nicola was planning to lock Canlin out of the house and kept a hammer under her sofa for protection.

Accused: Richard Canlin

During the afternoon of October 10, when prosecutors say Canlin struck, Nicola contacted Mr Thompsett to say he was ‘kicking off again’ because she had caught him stealing her prescription medicine and was refusing to leave her home, the court heard.

Nicola sent a message to Mr Thompsett, saying: “Hey, can you send police to mine please. He’s kicking off because I’ve caught him out stealing my meds again.”

She sent another message just a minute later that read: “Please.”

Nicola tried calling the police on 101, but there was no answer, the court heard.

She then sent two emails to a police officer, telling her Canlin was getting abusive and she ‘wanted him out’.

Mr Thompsett messaged Nicola telling her to call 999, the court heard. There is then no action on his phone for two hours.

The court was told that Mr Thompsett sent Nicola a message asking if she was OK, and 20 minutes later he received a message that read: “I’m OK, I’ve got to say a big sorry to Richard, he didn’t nick my meds I found them so please don’t ring the police, I’m letting him stay until October 19, anyway how are you babes?”

The prosecution argue that Canlin sent this message and by this time Nicola had already been fatally attacked.

Mr Thompsett told the court that he was supposed to go and see Nicola the following day (October 11), but she stopped replying to his messages.

He went over to her flat to see what was going on but there was no answer and he tried a number of other times after that which were also unsuccessful.

He said he received a text message from Canlin saying Nicola had asked him to tell him that Nicola had ‘gone off with an old boyfriend’ in Scotland. Canlin then invited him round.

Mr Thompsett went over and saw that her mobility scooter was there, along with her walking frame and medication, the court heard.

He told the court he asked Canlin why Nicola had left her stuff at home, and he replied saying she had ‘done it before’.

Mr Thompsett said he was confused and continued to visit the flat when he started to notice that Canlin had moved stuff around and had removed a photograph of Nicola and her two children.

He told the court that there was a ‘mouldy smell’ in the bedroom and there was different bedding on Nicola’s bed.

Mr Thompsett said Canlin told him that he had contacted the council to have the flat changed into his name.

He also said Canlin told him that he and Nicola were boyfriend and girlfriend, not brother and sister, the court heard.

Mr Thompsett told the court that Nicola had never said this was the case.

He said after Nicola disappeared, Canlin reached for the hammer under the sofa before brandishing it and saying: “If anybody comes in here I’ll whack them with this.”

Mr Thompsett said Canlin used drugs and he sometimes saw him do “brown rock” where he would smoke it in tin foil.

He told the court that he did not see Nicola take drugs at all.

A statement from one of Nicola’s friends, who has since passed away, was read out in court.

Her friend said when she tried to go and see Nicola, Canlin told her that she had fallen out of bed, burst stitches in her finger, which she had recently been in hospital for, and had been rushed to hospital in an ambulance.

During another visit to the flat, she said Canlin told her that Nicola had come at him with a hammer and threw a tin of beans at him. He then told her: “She really f****** pushes. Someone will kill her one day.”

Nicola’s friend continued to visit the flat, the court heard, and she noticed a strong smell of cleaning products and said Canlin had ‘gone mad cleaning’.

She said during another visit, Canlin told her that Nicola had gone to Scotland with another man, and talked about her ‘as if she was never coming back’.

Video footage of Canlin buying cleaning products at Aldi was shown to the jury – along with clips of him making several cash withdrawals on Nicola’s bank card after she disappeared.

Earlier, a jury heard that the 42-year-old had not reported her missing, and had lied to neighbours about her disappearance.

Nicola, who had survived cancer, was diagnosed with a spine injury at birth and needed medication for Russell-Silver syndrome, a form of dwarfism. She was 4ft 9ins tall and required a mobility scooter to get around.

Canlin, of no fixed address, denies murder and the trial is expected to last two weeks.

A message from the Editor:

Thank you for reading this story on our website. While I have your attention, I also have an important request to make of you.

The dramatic events of 2020 are having a major impact on many of our advertisers - and consequently the revenue we receive. We are now more reliant than ever on you taking out a digital subscription to support our journalism.

Subscribe to the Edinburgh Evening News online and enjoy unlimited access to trusted, fact-checked news and sport from Edinburgh and the Lothians. Visit https://www.edinburghnews.scotsman.com/subscriptions now to sign up.

By supporting us, we are able to support you in providing trusted, fact-checked content for this website.

Joy Yates