Edinburgh crime: Mother whose son died in alleged stabbing urges more security over knives on display in stores
An Edinburgh mother whose son died in an alleged stabbing has launched a new campaign for greater security around knives on display in shops and supermarkets.
Lisa Petrie says stores often take greater precautions over preventing the theft of computer games or alcohol.
Her son, John McNab, died in an incident in Leith in September, aged 22. A 16-year-old boy has been charged with his murder.


She is already campaigning for "bleed kits" containing a tourniquet, bandages and other equipment to be made available in public places to save other lives and has raised more than £3,000 to supply them.
Now she is also calling for supermarkets and other stores to do more to stop knives being shoplifted and later used in attacks.
She has launched a petition on change.org to "improve knife security in supermarkets and retail stores". It secured more than 500 signatures in the first 24 hours.
Lisa said: "My aim is to try and get these knives off the shelves or at least made less accessible to people."
She said she had heard a story that kids had stolen knives from one store and were "sword-fighting" outside. "One got nicked quite badly and ran off. But if the knives hadn't been so accessible they would not have been in that situation.
“In lot of stores at the moment, people can just pick the knives up and there's no security tag or anything on them. But when it comes to computer games, they display empty boxes and the assistant has to give them it at the till once it's been purchased.
"And in some places drink is all in closed cabinets and you need to buzz someone to get it. So why can't that be the same for knives?"
She has also been speaking to MPs and MSPs to rally support for her cause.
Pauline Bowie, director of Low Income Families Together, based at the Muirhouse Millennium Centre, who is helping Lisa, said: "In the UK, everyday items such as alcohol, razors, energy drinks, and even some computer games are locked behind cabinets or require staff assistance to purchase.
"Yet kitchen knives — which can be easily stolen and have been used in countless violent incidents — often sit openly on shelves without any security tags, locks, or checkout restrictions.
"We are calling for supermarkets and retail stores to take basic, reasonable steps to reduce the risk of knives falling into the wrong hands."
She said these could include locking knives in cabinets, as often happens with alcohol or razor blades; adding security tags to knife packaging; and keeping knives behind customer service counters.
"These changes would not restrict responsible adults from purchasing essential household items — they would simply add the same level of protection already applied to far less dangerous products.
"We urge retailers, local authorities, and policymakers to take immediate action to make our communities safer. Knife crime ruins lives, and increased retail security is a simple, practical step toward prevention."
*We’ve got a huge Black Friday subscription offer happening right now and there’s never been a better time to be a subscriber. Get a full year of the Edinburgh Evening News for just £1 a month for 12 months and unlock full access to premium reporting, insightful analysis and unlimited digital access for less than the cost of a weekly coffee.
The offer is only around for a limited period of time, so be quick and grab your discount now when you subscribe to our website. https://www.edinburghnews.scotsman.com/subscriptions