Edinburgh Labour MP warns against 'knee-jerk' move to topple Keir Starmer and tells party 'Keep calm, but don't carry on'

‘We cannot carry on, but now is not the time to lose our heads’ - Chris Murray MP

Edinburgh Labour MP Chris Murray has warned the party against rushing to change leader, saying it needs to "take a beat" and advising: "Keep calm, but don't carry on".

Mr Murray, who won Edinburgh East & Musselburgh from the SNP at the 2024 general election, said in the wake of the disappointing May 7 election results Labour had to work out what had gone wrong and how to correct it rather than topple Keir Starmer in a knee-jerk reaction.

Chris Murray said the May 7 election results were 'chastening' for Labourplaceholder image
Chris Murray said the May 7 election results were 'chastening' for Labour | TSPL

He told a post-election conference organised by Edinburgh University's Business School and the Scottish Fabians think tank that the results at Holyrood and elsewhere had been "chastening", with the party losing votes in multiple directions to the SNP, the Greens, Reform and the Lib Dems.

But he said: "The answer is not obvious, we've got to take a beat. The message to the rest of the party is a bit contradictory, it's 'Keep calm, but not carry on'. We need to be really clear and thoughtful about what the prescription for this situation is.

"In life, you get two types of warning - you get a tactical warning and a strategic warning: a tactical warning is you're having a heart attack; a strategic warning is: you're really overweight and do no exercise. We just got a strategic warning - that's not the moment for a tactical response, it's for a strategic response.

"We cannot make a decision like changing the leader or a brand new policy platform or shift to the left / shift to the right in a knee-jerk response. So I think, we cannot carry on, but now is not the time to lose our heads.

“I think it's a deeper challenge that we've got - it is a strategic one rather than one we can respond to with tactics.

“Yes, this is a tough time for the Labour party now, and the results in Scotland in particular were heartbreakingly bad, but we're still the government of the country.

"I don't think, as a Labour MP in a Labour government, that I should be in the business of decapitating a sitting Prime Minister without knowing where we're taking the party after that."

He said people should listen to what Andy Burnham and Wes Streeting were saying. "We should be open minded about that, but not just jumping off cliffs without seeing what's at the bottom of them."

The conference also heard, via video link, from Cowdenbeath & Kirkcaldy MP Melanie Ward, who resigned as a ministerial aide after the elections, calling for Keir Starmer to go.

She said the decision had been a hard one, but the right thing to do. “The stakes are so high if we get this wrong - it would be Nigel Farage and the far right taking over our country and all that would mean. It's not the Tories or a normal political party. We all know they are not a normal political party and they are hugely dangerous. That is the big threat staring us in the face. That's the reason why I and many others felt we were compelled to act.”

Speaking about the election campaign, she said: “It was really striking to me, door after door, the main reason people didn't want to vote Labour was because of Keir Starmer personally, but secondly they felt that change wasn't happening fast enough.”

She said people felt “personally betrayed” over the ending of winter fuel payments for all but the poorest pensioners.

And she continued: "In this day and age, when you are trying to fight an enemy like Nigel Farage, who speaks in primary colours, in language that regular people understand, our response is technocratic wonkery. We're trying to fight fascism with a spreadsheet and it's not very surprising that it's not working."

And she explained why she felt this was the time to act. "We're less than two years in, but the benefit of that is that if we make the change happen now we still have long enough left to start to bring about the kind of change we're seeking as a country and far enough in advance of the next election. We need to make this change happen now to make the very best we can of this Labour government.”

News you can trust since 1873
Follow us
© 2026 Iconic Media Group Ltd. All rights reserved.Cookie SettingsTerms and ConditionsPrivacy notice