Edinburgh MP slams 'disgusting' bonuses for Scottish Water chiefs after cleaning up sewage waste from hotspots

Edinburgh East and Musselburgh MP Chris Murray said that he has seen evidence in Portobello and Musselburgh of sewage spills

An Edinburgh MP has blasted Scottish Water for paying out huge bonuses to its executives over the past year despite ongoing pollution issues in his constituency.

Chris Murray, MP for Edinburgh East and Musselburgh, is writing to Scottish Government ministers to demand action after the latest Scottish Water accounts showed that bosses had been handed more than £250,000 of public money over the past year.

Chief Executive Alex Plant was handed a £115,000 bonus on top of his £315,000 salary, while chief financial officer Alan Dingwall was given £79,000 on top of his annual salary of £217,000.

Chief operating officer Peter Farrer bagged a £64,000 bonus on top of his £176,000 salary, bringing the total paid out in bonuses to £258,000.

Mr Murray has said that the bonuses are not reflected in the issues he continues to see in his constituency.

Chris Murray, MP for Edinburgh East and Musselburghplaceholder image
Chris Murray, MP for Edinburgh East and Musselburgh | National World

He told the Evening News: “Sewage is ending up on the beaches of Portobello and Musselburgh and not enough is being done to stop it. I have personally picked up items such as wet wipes, sanitary towels, and tampons which proves that sewage debris is ending up in that water.

“It is unbelievable that the chief executive of the company that does that is allowed to collect a bonus. This is a publicly owned company that is being allowed by the Scottish Government to pump sewage into the waters around Edinburgh. That is beyond disgusting.”

The £258,000 in bonuses were also paid out over the same period when customers were handed an 8.7 per cent price hike, which translated into a household average of around £42 extra each year.

Mr Murray, who is writing to Scottish Government bosses to address the issue, added that his constituents feel as though they are being “gaslit”.

He said: “People are denying there is a problem with sewage in Scottish waters. They're saying it's just a thing in England because of private water companies.

“But then they go to the beach and how else could sanitary towels and tampons be there if they hadn't come through the sewage system? I spoke out before and Scottish Water and SEPA sort of pushed back on it and said actually their analysis suggests it's seagull droppings that's causing this pollution. Well, seagulls don't use tampons.”

Portobello Beach. placeholder image
Portobello Beach. | Lisa Ferguson

Mr Murray added: “What kind of country allows a bonus of public money to happen when that occurs? He [chief executive Alex Plant] should have been hauled in front of the Scottish Parliament and hauled in front of ministers, not given a bonus if he allows that to happen to our seas and Scottish waters.

“He should not be getting a bonus while my constituents are literally swimming in s***.”

In response to Mr Murray’s criticism of the bonuses paid out to top bosses, Scottish Water said that remuneration for executives is “performance-based”, adding that it is also designed to attract high quality leaders.

A spokesperson for Scottish Water said: "Performance-related payments are part of an organisation-wide scheme that applies across Scottish Water. It is not automatic and is payable only if the organisation meets performance targets."

"In 2025/26, Scottish Water delivered its second-best year for operational performance, including record customer satisfaction, its lowest ever number of serious pollution incidents, high drinking water quality and continued progress on the largest investment programme in its history."

A Scottish Government spokesperson said: “Scottish Water is subject to independent economic regulation, one of the most transparent and demanding improvement regimes of any public body in Scotland. We expect it to continue outperforming the tough efficiency targets set by its regulator.

“Like any large organisation, Scottish Water must compete with the private sector to attract and retain the skilled people needed to run the business and deliver the improvements government has asked for. Bonuses are only paid when demanding, independently verified targets are exceeded.

“The remuneration package for the Chief Executive and senior team, including salary and bonus, remains significantly lower than at comparable utility companies.”

News you can trust since 1873
Follow us
© 2026 Iconic Media Group Ltd. All rights reserved.Cookie SettingsTerms and ConditionsPrivacy notice