Bathers forced to contend with 'dangerous waste' in Edinburgh waters, Holyrood told
‘The SNP’s overall record on water safety is extremely poor’ - Sanne Dijkstra-Downie MSP
The Scottish Government has been urged to "finally start cleaning up" Edinburgh’s sewage-plagued waters amid warnings that bathers are being forced to swim alongside dangerous waste.
Ministers are facing mounting pressure over the condition of the city's waterways, with concerns raised at Holyrood over pollution at popular spots including the Water of Leith, Wardie Bay and Portobello.
Edinburgh Northern Lib Dem MSP Sanne Dijkstra-Downie highlighted the issue in the Scottish Parliament, asking when the government would commission promised feasibility studies on bringing sections of the Water of Leith and Wardie Bay into safe public usage.
Both have had problems with pollution, including sewage contamination, and residents are said to have been deterred from using them because of the water condition.


In addition, Ms Dijkstra-Downie said, dredging had taken place over several days during the bathing season in August, putting bathers at further risk.
She said: “The beach is right next to a working harbour. To protect public health and water quality, the Scottish Environment Protection Agency (SEPA) stipulates that no dredging should take place within 2km of bathing waters between 1 June and 15 September, but, in August of this year, dredging and raking took place there over several days.”
Climate Action Secretary Gillian Martin said the government was developing proposals to deliver safe public access to waters. “As an initial step, I will commission a scoping study to identify the best approach for increasing public amenity use of waters in urban environments. That study will consider both historical and current sources of contamination, any water quality improvements that are required, public safety considerations, technical feasibility and likely costs.”
Afterwards, Ms Dijkstra-Downie said: “The Water of Leith and Wardie Bay are among Edinburgh’s most treasured places, yet the safe management needed to ensure they are fit for public use has never materialised. The SNP’s overall record on water safety is extremely poor.
“As things stand, people who want to use these waters have to contend with sewage and dangerous waste, sometimes right next to their homes. It cannot go on.”
Ms Dijstra-Downie added: “While I was pleased to see a commitment to bringing these waters into safe usage in John Swinney’s programme for government, we have already waited too long for action. I will continue to push the government hard to make Edinburgh’s waters safe as soon as possible.”
Kate Nevens, Green MSP for Edinburgh and Lothians East, said water quality and water safety were a huge concern not only in Wardie Bay and the Water of Leith, but also in Portobello, the Tyne, Aberlady bay and the River Esk, among others.
She said: “The issue is being exacerbated by heavy rainfall and more frequent flooding, as we have seen recently at Seafield. Data is not being collected anywhere near frequently enough to keep people safe.”
And she asked what the government was doing to ensure more frequent testing of water quality and communicate water quality data and pollution risk to the public in a clear and accessible manner.
Ms Martin told her: “We need to look at each location as a distinct entity, because every location can present unique challenges. I have asked for an investigation to be undertaken into the issues at Portobello, so that we can see where the contamination is coming from.
“Until we have a clear picture of where the contamination is coming from, we will not be able to put in place the processes and the investment that are needed to bring those waters up to the standard that the people who use them would expect.”