Edinburgh's Marionville fire station's crucial role underlined as SFRS board meets to decide future
‘We always knew there was another option’ - Sinead McNulty, Living Rent
The importance of saving Edinburgh’s Marionville fire station has been underlined by figures showing its crews dealt with more than half the fires in Holyrood Park over the last 10 years.
The station’s fire engine was called to 129 of the 203 fires in the park between June 2016 and June 2026, according to official figures obtained under Freedom of Information by Miles Briggs, Conservative MSP for Edinburgh and Lothians East.


Marionville was proposed for closure under a Scotland-wide review by the Scottish Fire and Rescue Service, with its fire engine and crew to be relocated to Newcraighall. But after a huge community campaign to save the station, the final recommendation when the SFRS board meets on Monday is not to proceed with the plan.
However, the report to the board leaves the long-term future of the station uncertain, saying there should be "further detailed analysis and modelling of potential station locations in the Edinburgh area" and that Marionville should remain open while that work is carried out.
Mr Briggs said: “The figures received this week show the importance of Marionville to the local community and Holyrood Park over the last decade.
“Those living and working in the East Edinburgh area are already seeing public services stretched to the limit but shutting down Marionville would only pile on risk.
“While it is welcome that the Fire Chief has heard the concerns of the community and recommended dropping plans for the closure, we must note his definitive caveat that ‘no final decisions have yet been taken.’


“The station is not home and dry yet. We cannot leave the future of this indispensable service up to chance. I urge everyone to get behind this campaign and ensure fire bosses on Monday choose to protect Marionville and the local community once and for all.”
Marionville firefighters were the first to arrive at the large grass fire on Arthur's Seat last month, reaching the site within two or three minutes of the alarm being raised. And the crew played a vital role in getting members of the public off the hill quickly as the fire began to spread.
And a crew from Marionville was first on the scene at a severe fire in a four-story block of flats at the corner of Sleigh Drive and Restalrig Road South on June 9.
Local people feared closure of Marionville would increase risk because of slower response times. And SFRS admitted that it could take firefighters up to six minutes longer to reach fires. Other concerns included the large number of new homes being planned in the area, the reindustrialisation of Leith Docks and the growing number of grass fires in Holyrood Park.
Sinead McNulty from tenants' union Living Rent, who played a big part in the campaign to save Marionville, said the community had seen too many public services being cut and the fire station meant a lot to people.
She said: "I'm pleased they've made this recommendation because it seemed before they were saying closing it was the only option - and I guess we always knew there was another option.
"And I think that's a really important lesson of this - quite often things are pushed through, not thinking of the impact on the city or the community or people, but for money-saving or whatever. This recommendation shows it was always possible.


"Living Rent did loads of community stalls at Lidl and Morrisons, with the community council, in the street, at Easter Road, and everybody said it was a terrible idea and it was really important to keep it open because the closure of these resources in working class communities is something that happens again and again and once it's gone it doesn't come back.
"We got a really strong response from people. And from the petition and the stalls and the consultation day, people were talking about different contacts with the fire station and I think Marionville has a really big impact on the community in Lochend, Craigentinny, Restalrig and Meadowbank and that would obviously be lost if it was taken away."
Local resident Agnieszka Barys, a member of Living Rent, said saving the fire station was crucial. "Just a few weeks ago we had a huge fire on the top floor of flats in Restalrig. If Marionville was closed, the response time for that would have increased by up to six minutes and that whole building could have been destroyed.


"And just before that we had a huge fire on Arthur's Seat and it was Marionville that responded as the closest fire station. We have to keep that fire station running as long as we possibly can. It's not just a fire station, it's our local hub for local activities."
And she said it was not the first time the community had had to rally round to save the station. "In the last two decades they have tried to close it three times. We have to find a permanent solution - we have to rebuild the fire station in that location. We got so many signatures on our petition, we got huge support in the local community. We have been successful this time, but will we be next time? That's the big question."
Alice McAulay, a member of Lochend, Craigentinny and Meadowbank community council, said she was relieved when she heard about the recommendation not to go ahead with the closure.
"Everybody felt really quite anxious at the prospect of it going. The campaign definitely brought people together. People came together from every part of the community, different organisations and different political parties - and you felt the strength of the community. It was really quite powerful - and to be heard was amazing.
"It is quite a deprived part of town and I think people do feel quite despondent about the things they ask for and aren't given, so it's quite important."
But she said the pressure would have to be kept up because the recommendation did not guarantee the fire station’s long-term future. "It's going to be an ongoing fight, I think."