Holyrood committee split on support for Edinburgh MP Ash Regan's Bill on prostitution
The Holyrood committee scrutinising Edinburgh Eastern MSP Ash Regan's Bill to criminalise the buying of sex have split over whether the proposal should proceed or not.
The report by the Scottish Parliament's criminal justice committee, published today ahead of a Stage 1 vote on the general principles of the Bill on February 3, said four members were recommending the principles be agreed to, although they believed the Bill needed "substantial amendment"; but the other four believed the Bill should not progress any further.
Ms Regan's Bill would create a new criminal offence of paying for a sexual act, with those convicted facing fines of up to £10,000 and possible jail time.


The existing offence of loitering, soliciting or importuning in a public place for the purposes of prostitution would be scrapped; those found guilty of this offence in the past would have their convictions quashed; and those trying to leave prostitution would be given the right to support.
The committee report said all members agreed that prostitution was a form of violence against women and children that often impacted the most vulnerable in society, and that there must be urgent action to tackle it.
The four opposition members - Labour's Pauline McNeill and Katy Clark and Tories Liam Kerr and Sharon Dowey - wanted the Bill to proceed, with amendments being scrutinised, and argued it would be wrong to curtail the debate given the failure to legislate to reform the law over many years.
But the four SNP members - Jamie Hepburn, Fulton MacGregor, Rona Mackay and Audrey Nicoll - said evidence heard about the risk to women’s safety from criminalising the purchase of sex could not be ignored.
And they argued there had been limited time to explore those concerns fully and felt there was insufficient time to consult on and make any necessary changes to the Bill between now and the end of the parliamentary session.
The committee voiced concern about whether the new offence of purchasing sex could be adequately enforced, given it takes place in private.
The report noted there was widespread support for repealing the offence of soliciting and said it was more appropriate for women in prostitution to be supported rather than criminalised. But it recognised the Scottish Government had said further consultation would be needed.
On quashing historic convictions, the committee said it might be more appropriate for individuals to apply for a disregard.
And while it backed support for women exiting prostitution it raised questions about making it a statutory right and how it would be funded.
The committee also said that if the Bill falls, it hoped new proposals would be introduced in the next session of parliament. And it recommended the Scottish Government should establish an independent commission in the first year of the new parliament to consider the damage done by the global sex trade, the prevalence of violence against women and girls and misogyny, the support needed for those in prostitution or seeking to exit, and the evidence of other countries who had recently reformed their laws on the issues.
Committee convener Audrey Nicoll said: “Our key concern when considering this Bill is will it make women and girls safer and while every committee member recognises the harms of prostitution and supports the goal of reducing its prevalence, our committee is unable to achieve consensus on whether this Bill will achieve that.
“The conflicting evidence we have heard on the impact of this Bill has made our decision on whether to back it extremely difficult, and the differing positions of committee members show that each of us has considered their position in great detail.
“Given the evidence is not definitive and is highly contested, each committee member has had to make a judgement as to where the balance of evidence lies and which lines of argument appear to us to be the most persuasive.
“All members of the committee agree with the urgency for action to reduce harms and to support those involved in prostitution, and that more must be done to address wider issues such as human trafficking and the prevention of violence against women and girls.
“It will now be for each MSP across the parliament to consider the evidence and conclusions in our report and to decide whether or not they will back this Bill at Stage 1.”