Holyrood elections 2026: Why overall majority in Scottish Parliament is not test of legitimacy

Little sign that any UK Government will agree to another independence referendum

A lot of the conversation during this election campaign has been about whether the SNP will get an overall majority of seats in the new parliament.

That’s because First Minister John Swinney has set that as his goal, saying he will use it as a mandate to demand that Westminster agrees to another referendum on independence.

A march for independence organised through Edinburgh by Believe in Scotland on March 28, 2026.placeholder image
A march for independence organised through Edinburgh by Believe in Scotland on March 28, 2026. | PA

Counting the SNP and Greens together, there was a pro-independence majority at Holyrood in both the 2016 and 2021 parliaments, but that was not enough to persuade successive prime ministers that there should be a repeat of the 2014 vote on Scotland’s future.

Fair enough, then, for Mr Swinney to argue that a stand-alone SNP overall majority should trigger a second referendum, since that was the precedent set when the first one was held.

But the Edinburgh Agreement between David Cameron and Alex Salmond paving the way for the 2014 vote was signed in different times, when UK politicians felt confident of an overwhelming No vote, when the UK was still in the EU and when politics wasn’t quite as toxic as it feels today. And there is nothing binding about the 2014 precedent.

There are conflicting predictions on whether the SNP will get an overall majority. One poll at the weekend said it would (66 seats), another said not (57 seats).

However, there is little sign that any likely UK government will agree to another independence referendum even if Mr Swinney does reach or surpass the magic 65 seats,

But if he doesn’t, that’s not a failure. The electoral system for the Scottish Parliament was specifically designed for parties not to get an overall majority.

Winning more votes than all the other parties put together may be seen as crucial at Westminster where coalitions or minority government are seen as aberrations. But Holyrood’s proportional representation system is intended to create a a parliament where parties need to co-operate and work together to get anything passed.

The fact Alex Salmond led the SNP to an overall majority in 2011 was an historic achievement, but it should never become the expected goal for succeeding governments, far less a test of legitimacy.

News you can trust since 1873
Follow us
© 2026 Iconic Media Group Ltd. All rights reserved.Cookie SettingsTerms and ConditionsPrivacy notice