Try ‘devo max’ for 10 years to see if independence pays off, says Labour peer Lord Haughey

‘If I thought that the people were better off, I'd vote for independence’ - Lord Willie Haughey

Labour supporting Scottish entrepreneur Lord Willie Haughey has suggested Scotland should be allowed to try full fiscal autonomy for 10 years to see if independence would make people better off.

Speaking at a post-election conference in Edinburgh, the millionaire businessman also said Ivan McKee, the new Cabinet Secretary for Public Sector Reform, had been handed a poisoned chalice.

Lord Willie Haugheyplaceholder image
Lord Willie Haughey | Supplied

And he predicted cuts to public services as well as voluntary redundancies among civil servants as the Scottish Government sought to address the forecast £4.7 billion deficit.

Lord Haughey told the conference, organised by Edinburgh University’s Business School and the Scottish Fabians think tank, that tackling the deficit was the number one issue for the newly re-elected SNP government.

He said: "If Scotland was a business it would be bankrupt, we'd have the administrators in just now. If we continue down that path, with other leading politicians talking about more things to be given away free, the next time an election comes round we'll probably be sitting around £8.7 billion of a deficit."

He contrasted Scotland's economic position with Ireland's current surplus of £12 billion. "Charlie Haughey (former Irish Taoiseach) away back in the day transformed things - he made difficult decisions. He made the decisions that Ivan McKee is going to have to make. But it gave him a foundation to build upon."

The Irish government had opted for low taxes to attract inward investment. "I think there's 100 large American companies operate in Ireland generating all sorts of taxes for the Irish economy."

Lord Haughey said he had studied the 'Singapore model' - low taxes and minimal regulation - and said Scotland needed to "think out of the box".

He continued: "I said to Alex Salmond many years ago 'If you can show me a great economic plans or Scotland you might convince me to vote for being independent."

But he said Scotland's position had got worse every year. "I think there's people within the SNP who are talking about independence and I think they'd be frightened to death if they got it tomorrow."

And he asked: "Why is nobody talking about fiscal autonomy? Why don't we have fiscal autonomy for 10 years and let the people decide if we're better on our own or not?

"I think there are huge economic upsides to being part of the UK. But if someone was bold enough tomorrow to give us complete fiscal autonomy in Scotland to see if we could demonstrate we would be better off - if I thought that the people, and I mean all of the people, were better off, I'd vote for independence.”

Full fiscal autonomy, sometimes called devo max, would see Scotland take control of all taxes and pay an agreed sum to the UK government to cover reserved responsibilities such as defence and foreign affairs.

Lord Haughey said he hoped entrepreneurship would be “at the heart” of everything the newly re-elected government wanted to do.

And on Mr McKee’s role in charge of public sector reform, he said: “We have increased the civil service by 22.000 since 2014. When you have a deficit, you look at two things - how can we generate more money and how can we cut? It looks like he's been given the poisoned chalice. I think what you'll see in the next few months is there'll be voluntary redundancies and no jobs will be replace and I think we'll see a substantial cut in public services. He's got a fancy title, but I think he's going to be the hatchet man."

News you can trust since 1873
Follow us
© 2026 Iconic Media Group Ltd. All rights reserved.Cookie SettingsTerms and ConditionsPrivacy notice