Leading SNP politician says she fears for tenor of debate at Holyrood if Reform get into parliament

A senior SNP politician has said she "fears for the tenor of debate" in the Scottish Parliament if Reform candidates are elected to Holyrood in May's elections.

Housing Secretary Mairi McAllan - tipped as a future First Minister - spoke of a climate in politics where "the temperature and volume is ever increasing".

Addressing a hustings in Edinburgh's Assembly Rooms, organised by Scotland 2050 and The Scotsman, she criticised Reform leader Malcolm Offord for refusing to apologise again for a "joke" he made in 2018 which has been branded racist and homophobic.

The SNP’s Mairi McAllan spoke of her fears if Reform gets into parliament. Picture: Lisa Ferguson.placeholder image
The SNP’s Mairi McAllan spoke of her fears if Reform gets into parliament. Picture: Lisa Ferguson. | Lisa Ferguson/The Scotsman

Asked if Reform was partly responsible for an increase toxicity in Scottish politics, Mr Offord said his party was running a positive campaign and he had made no personal attacks on anyone.

Ms McAllan said: "I think that's an astonishing failure to acknowledge the hurt and disgust that was caused by your own comments, Malcolm. I think also what I find particularly distasteful is the fact that your explanation said 'well, I made a donation' - throwing money at the problem, as though that could get you away from how distasteful and homophobic your comments were. You really ought to have taken the opportunity tonight to apologise.

“But this is feeding into a wider climate in our politics, where the temperature and volume is ever increasing and it doesn't serve our people."

She said debate had to be robust but respectful. And she continued: "I genuinely fear for the tenor of the debate in the Scottish Parliament if, led by a man who can't apologise for a deeply offensive so-called joke, [Reform] are returned to the Scottish Parliament."

Mr Offord insisted: "I made a bad joke eight years ago, before I was in public life; I made a fulsome apology at that time and made amends. It was eight years ago - that is done and dusted."

But former Green co-leader Patrick Harvie said he felt “nauseous” even thinking about Mr Offord’s comments. And he said “outright racism” was being normalised across large parts of the political spectrum.

“I have met hospital workers and care workers who have been assaulted, who have been on the receiving end of racist abuse at work, because of this rising tide of hostility and toxic politics.

“We see where it ends up when we look across to the US. We see what began as political discontent is now embodied in gangs of masked, armed thugs raiding people’s homes and businesses and workplaces and schools and colleges, abducting people and throwing them into privatised concentration camp cages ready for deportation. And Reform say they want to reproduce the state violence of ICE in the UK.”

Labour's Martin Whitfield also spoke of the toxic character of politics. As well as social media, there were also now personal attacks on the doorstep. "We have had situations where the police have had to get involved," he said.

"And it's because that level of give is now so small that when people fee they are empowered to say things they go ahead and do that.

"The challenge we face is that the behaviour that has been shown by adults, both on social media and in events, is now moving down to our children in schools and you see the misogyny female teachers and female staff are facing from not just teenage boys, but pre-teenage boys."

He said boundaries which young people naturally pushed against, but which used not to move, were now suddenly flexing because of influencers in the US and elsewhere. And he said young people felt empowered "to treat other people as less than themselves”.

"I go back to the words of [murdered MP] Jo Cox, that we do all have more in common and if we can't learn to disagree agreeably we will reap that in the way out young people grow up, with a lack of understanding about what the community and what social boundaries are.

“If we allow ourselves to go down the road of vehemence, of anger at the other, of being told that someone different is the cause of your problems, what comes about from that is our young people being unable to learn and find out what it is to be part of a community. That loss is tragic.

“And I think this election, particularly in Scotland, is going to be a Rubicon moment for that and it is for all of us to step up to that responsibility, call it out when it occurs and show what proper disagreement, agreeably done, is about.”

News you can trust since 1873
Follow us
© 2026 Iconic Media Group Ltd. All rights reserved.Cookie SettingsTerms and ConditionsPrivacy notice