Leith’s watershed moment for small independent shops - Kevin Buckle
In the news this week was the move some found baffling that Waterstones, who left Ocean Terminal while it was redeveloped, had chosen to open a branch at the Newkirkgate Centre in Leith, just a short distance from the independent book shop Argonaut Books.
Argonaut Books are of course based on Leith Walk so their concern is understandable, that they are concerned, as being a retailer on the high street is not easy at the best of times. I don’t know enough about the book industry to be an expert on the ins and outs of how how hard it is for a small independent to compete with a big chain, but I can be fairly sure, as with the music industry I operate in, that while suppliers will talk a good game about supporting independents, in reality the chain will be able to dictate terms to a large extent.


Having said that Waterstones does have one disadvantage over HMV and that is they are financially fairly secure. Bizarrely HMV’s position, having gone bust twice, is that if the record companies don’t give them all they ask for, and if landlords don’t accept massively reduced rents, then they will simply cease to exist.
Record companies are not prepared to gamble that other businesses would replace HMV if they closed down completely, and landlords with high street shops look at the number of vacancies on the high street and take the view that some money is better than none at all. Consequently HMV are now in a position in which they only pay for stock once it is sold, which also means they don’t have to pay for stock that is stolen.
When it comes to rent they have moved many of their shops to wherever they can get the best deal, above all other considerations go out of the window, which is why they chose the shops they currently have in Edinburgh against the advice of some within the company. After FOPP was forced to close it was bought by HMV, so it too has all the trading advantages of HMV while suffering from the same poor location decisions that in Edinburgh took them to Shandwick Place.
My shop Avalanche of course thrived when it was next to FOPP in Cockburn Street, showing that close competition can sometimes be a good thing, but for Argonaut books – open for only the relatively short time of four years – to go up against a business owned by one of the biggest management investment companies in the world, the scenario is very different.
What any independent business needs is support from the local community and regular customers, and here bookshops do have an advantage. Music buyers have a third option when choosing between a chain and an independent and that is to buy a huge array of “extras” not available in shops directly from the artists.While publishers set up websites for writers the way record companies do for artists, there is a limited amount that can be done with a book beyond having it signed or occasionally giving it a different cover and shops will often have signed copies too.Customers can more easily support their local independent without missing out. Hopefully Waterstones will bring even more book buyers to the area who will then decide to support an independent.