A Royal revamp is needed, if the institution wants to survive in the 21st century - George Foulkes
It seems each new Royal trip to a commonwealth country or former colony comes with renewed calls for reparations, and those calls only grew louder as the King embarked on his most recent all-expenses-paid excursion to the Caribbean.
Whether or not you agree that these nations are entitled to recompense, from either the King or the British state, I believe it should motivate us all to reconsider the Royal legacy a little closer to home.


While the people of Britain did not suffer anything like the horrors of the Atlantic slave trade, we have been subjects – in one form or another – to this Royal family for hundreds of years and, while the modern monarchy plays a relatively benevolent role nowadays, they still preside over a wealth of land and resources that should belong to the state.
Setting aside the crown estates, which do technically generate revenues for the Treasury, the King privately owns approximately 53,000 acres of land in Scotland, alone. This land is all private property and produces no public revenue for the public purse. In many cases, these assets cannot be sold and they are often partially open to visitors, but they represent a legacy of Royal conquest in Britain which does not sit comfortably within a democracy.


In addition to these private holdings, the Royals are also funded through a mechanism called the Sovereign Grant. You could be forgiven for not knowing what this is, as the grant is set by parliament yet subject to very little scrutiny. Originally introduced by Tory chancellor George Osborne, it was supposed to depoliticise how we fund the monarchy, but it has actually largely obscured it via a complex mechanism which ties the Royal budget to Crown estate profits.
These profits recently soared, due to a quirk of the system which means the crown estate owns the immediate stretch of seabed directly around our coastline, which just so happens to be in extremely high demand due to the boom in offshore wind projects.
Tying the grant to these profits might sound reasonable if you think there’s a chance they might decrease once all the accessible bits of sea-bed have been sold off. However, the link is also frozen against losses, so the Royals receive a guaranteed income and can profit immensely when CE profits soar (the government did step in to halve the rate from 25 per cent to 12 per cent of profits, but this is still a substantial chunk of entirely unearned wealth).
The common defence of a royal budget is that they need this money to enable them to act as diplomatic representatives of the nation. Without it they would be unable to function as renowned and beloved state dignitaries, and we should all be grateful to them for the huge amount of tourism they generate from living in our palaces and dressing in gold-embroidered robes. I think this argument fails to hold up for two reasons.
First, we already have a diplomatic corps. This comprises highly qualified, multi-lingual civil servants who manage to negotiate our trade deals and spread real British values, such as democracy, on significantly lower budgets.
And second, if you really are wedded to the idea of keeping the Royals around – and I must admit I do think that they will continue to play a role in our state apparatus for the immediate future – then why can’t they operate on a comparable budget to the other surviving monarchies in Europe, which have effectively extended their reign and endeared themselves to their citizens, through streamlining and cost-cutting.
In Spain, the public grant is about £7 million; in Sweden, it is under £15 million, and in the Netherlands, it is £45 million. Even if we were to take the baseline for our own Royal family in 2011 - £31 million - and adjust that for inflation, our sovereign grant should be around £50 million, not the £99.9 million core grant which is proposed.