A tale of two MSPs exposes the ethical divisions in Holyrood - Susan Dalgety

There is an old saying that voters get the government they deserve. Its most basic meaning is that politicians do not emerge from a vacuum. If a society is corrupt, then its politicians are likely to be criminal as well.

If the statement is true, then the average Scottish voter must be really stupid, because most of our MSPs are muppets. Harsh? Yes, about the average Scottish voter, because most of us are not daft. But many of our elected representatives are indeed muppets.

Let’s examine the evidence by looking at the case of Regan v. Constance. Ash Regan is the independent MSP for Edinburgh Eastern. She is one of Holyrood’s hardest working MSPs. She has principles. She resigned as a government minister because she could not support the SNP’s gender recognition reform bill.

She is currently steering a member’s bill through parliament to outlaw the purchase of sex. A law which would change Scottish society for the better and protect the most vulnerable women from sexual exploitation. It has attracted support from across the UK and the rest of the world.

It is fair to say that Regan works harder than your average member of the Scottish parliament and nor is she tied to any political party. She is following in the footsteps of another charismatic nationalist MSP, Margo MacDonald, and standing as an independent candidate in the May elections.

Then there is Angela Constance. The Justice Minister has been an MSP since 2007 and has risen without trace since. She has held a series of ministerial roles, from children’s services to social security.

She presided for three years over Scotland’s drugs policy, unable to do anything about our shameful drugs deaths – the highest by some margin in Europe. She is currently the Justice Secretary.

Both women have recently been the subject of controversy. Last week, independent advisers found that Angela Constance had breached the ministerial code in relation to comments she had made about Professor Alexis Jay, the UK’s leading expert in child sexual exploitation. A breach of the ministerial code usually demands resignation. Constance was given a written reprimand.

On the same day that Constance got away with it, Ash Regan was suspended from the Scottish Parliament for two days. Her crime? She publicly shared a letter she had sent to the Presiding Officer about Green MSP Maggie Chapman’s comments on the UK Supreme Court’s For Women Scotland ruling.

She wrote: “I’ve formally reported Maggie Chapman MSP to the Presiding Officer and Standards Committee following her dangerous dismissal of the Supreme Court’s ruling on the Equality Act as a ‘political attack’. MSPs have a duty to uphold the law, not undermine it.”

MSPs voted 84 to 18 with six abstentions to punish Ash Regan. Jeremy Balfour, another independent MSP, was the only Edinburgh or Lothian representative, apart from Regan herself, to vote against her suspension.

It is hard not to compare the fate of the two women: Constance protected by a government machine desperate not to lose a minister so close to an election. Regan, punished for speaking out.

But come May, it will be the people who decide who they want in their parliament. Let’s hope we make the right decision.

News you can trust since 1873
Follow us
© 2026 Iconic Media Group Ltd. All rights reserved.Cookie SettingsTerms and ConditionsPrivacy notice