Ash and Sue are a big loss to women’s causes at Holyrood - Susan Dalgety
Politics is a tough profession, made even harder by the inescapable fact that you can be unceremoniously tossed out of office by the electorate, even if you have been very good at your job.
Take Ash Regan and Sue Webber for example, two Edinburgh MSPs who lost their seats in the recent election.


Ash Regan, the MSP for Edinburgh East for five years, was a hard-working representative and the first SNP minister ever to resign a government position on a point of principle.
She stood down in protest at the gender reform legislation that Nicola Sturgeon was determined to push through Holyrood at the time.


Ash put herself forward as an independent candidate in this month’s poll, an almost impossible task given the dominance of political parties. And so it proved. The nearly 2000 votes she picked up were not enough to see her returned as an MSP.
In a thoughtful social media post a few days ago, she thanked everyone who had voted for her and warmly congratulated those who were elected.
“Public office is privilege and a heavy responsibility. I hope all those elected will exercise good judgement, show integrity and always put the interests of the country before party or ideology,” she said.
In her last Evening News column, Sue Webber looked back at her political career as first an Edinburgh councillor, then a list MSP, in particular her successful campaign to save Currie High School from closure.
On behalf of my grandchildren, twins Arran and Iona, who are enjoying the benefits of their wonderful new school, can I just say, thanks Sue.
And thank you too for your support in the fight for women’s rights. Your voice, like Ash’s, was very important in a parliament that sometimes seemed as if it had turned its back on women.
There are several new Edinburgh and Lothian MSPs to replace Ash and Sue and the three other politicians who lost their seat. Labour’s Martin Whitfield and the independent Jeremy Balfour will also be big losses to the parliament.
The SNP’s Angus Robertson less so, but there are rumours that he is eyeing up the Aberdeen Westminster seat made vacant by the election of his colleague, Stephen Flynn. You can’t keep an ambitious career politician down for long.
Perhaps the most ‘interesting’ of the new intake is Dr Q Manivannan of the Scottish Greens, who made headlines before they even got their feet under their new desk.
Manivannan says he is ‘trans” and prefers the pronouns they/them instead of he/him, so out of politeness I will indulge them. Manivannan, from India, is not a Scottish citizen.
They are here on a student visa which runs out later this year. They have applied for a 3-year graduate visa which, if they secure it, means they can continue in their new role until 2029.
The next Holyrood elections are in 2031. I don’t have any advice on visas for that two-year gap, but I do hope Manivannan takes note of Ash Regan’s thoughtful words and puts the interests of their adopted country before their ideology.
Our parliament was established to work on behalf of the people of Scotland, not as a soapbox for personal causes.