Candidates memo: it’s election time, not silly season - Iain Whyte

In elections candidates are usually told to stick to the party line and say nothing that might get them spotted for the wrong reasons. It seems that some Edinburgh candidates haven’t got the memo.

I thought the election silly season was over when I wrote last week about a Green candidate wanting to abolish all prisons but this week it was the SNP’s turn.

Deidre Brockplaceholder image
Deidre Brock

Deidre Brock, their candidate in Edinburgh Southern, was openly laughed at by an audience when she told a local husting that “reading, writing and arithmetic is not something she subscribes to in education, because modern kids have calculators and the internet”.

The amusing social media content followed with faux misspellings reminiscent of her colleague Kate Campbell’s real leaflet from earlier in the campaign which misspelled both education and independence.

I’m as happy as anyone to poke fun at opponents, but the real point is that this attitude betrays a fundamental lack of a serious approach to education policy. After all, if you don’t learn the basics of reading and the comprehension of writing how can you even interpret the material the internet throws up? How can you critically appraise it to know what’s true? How do you communicate clearly to the public in an election flyer?

Equally, without understanding arithmetic, how do operate the calculator to manage personal finances or tell whether politicians are being straight about taxation and spending?

Ms Brock is an experienced politician. She has served as an MP here in the city and was previously a councillor for eight years, spending time on the council’s education committee.

As her SNP Scottish Government has watched Scottish educational standards decline over their 20 years in power, while failing on their key mission to close the poverty-related attainment gap, the statistics show a remarkable move in the opposite direction in England.

Under Conservative education secretary, Michael Gove, the English system focused on attainment, rigorously applied the teaching of phonics and improved pupil behaviour and concentration. Some of the biggest improvements in performance came in the most deprived areas, especially in inner London.

After many years of preaching “progressive” policies the education committee Ms Brock once served on would rather avoid discussing attainment.

As you go to the polls think about who is being serious about public policy, not just talking up giveaways or “independence”. Judge politicians on whether they advocate for what really works.

News you can trust since 1873
Follow us
© 2026 Iconic Media Group Ltd. All rights reserved.Cookie SettingsTerms and ConditionsPrivacy notice