City tram vision without resources is a hallucination - Iain Whyte

Last week I wrote about the results of the council’s consultation on building a second tram line. The key takeaway was that more than half of the Edinburgh public were opposed.

Yesterday at Transport Committee we saw just how determined some councillors are to ignore your views and push through officers’ plans to keep spending your money on something you don’t want.

The business case alone for a second tram line would cost £50mplaceholder image
The business case alone for a second tram line would cost £50m

In advance of the meeting, I tabled a proposal to stop the work on trams in line with public opposition. I highlighted that the business case will cost up to £50m when there is no external source of funding and no plan to get the £3bn needed to build the thing.

On the contrary, the Scottish Government has said outright it won’t fund any of this, even the business case development. Meanwhile, senior Labour councillors have admitted the council can’t and won’t fund the build costs.

At the start of the meeting the transport convener ruled our proposal out of order. Apparently, we were seeking to make a decision when we were just being asked to note the consultation. Decisions are to be saved for September.

I am not happy and neither should you be. There is an ongoing cost in officer time and money between now and September that could be spent fixing existing infrastructure rather than dreaming up new tram fantasies.

Strangely, the convener did allow proposals from other political parties deciding how officers would report on ways forward. He just wouldn’t allow a decision to stop.

One of those proposals came from the Lib Dems, who may have described the tram plan without funding as a fantasy to the Evening News. But unlike we Conservatives, they aren’t prepared to back up their talk with action and cancel the spending.

The council is excellent at producing glossy documents and grand plans, it isn’t so good at funding or executing them.

If they press ahead with developing a business case, the £50m amounts to £200 per household in Council Tax. Quite a sum to waste when we are struggling to fund education and social care, remove weeds or repair the roads and pavements.

Author Thomas L Friedman once said, "a vision without resources is a hallucination".

In wasting your money by ignoring democracy the council will quickly hit the reality that big ideas are meaningless without the practical means to bring them to life.

News you can trust since 1873
Follow us
© 2026 Iconic Media Group Ltd. All rights reserved.Cookie SettingsTerms and ConditionsPrivacy notice