Council faces questions over listed building inaction - Kate Campbell

The C-listed George Cinema is considered a notable example of Art Deco architecture but it’s more than that to local people. The contours of this beloved building form part of the heritage, the identity and the fabric of Portobello.

After ten years of campaigning, the George is at serious risk of demolition – again. And this time it could be fatal. The owners have lodged an application to demolish the building.

SNP MSP Kate Campbellplaceholder image
SNP MSP Kate Campbell

In 2016, the George was in use as a bingo hall. It closed and was bought by the current owners. Now, you cannot enter without serious PPE due to airborne asbestos. The building has gone from regular use to disrepair in their hands.

The community, the Friends of the George and the local elected representatives have all raised concerns. Documenting the decline in a series of emails to the planning enforcement team: exposed steelwork, holes in the roof, banks of earth piled up against the walls.

The former George Cinema in Bath Street, Portobello, was an expansive complex with a skittle alley, billiards tables, and a clutch of shops with a large auditorium. It closed and was converted into a bingo hall in 1972. A local campaign was launched in 2023 to save the C-listed building from ruin after it has lain empty for seven years.placeholder image
The former George Cinema in Bath Street, Portobello, was an expansive complex with a skittle alley, billiards tables, and a clutch of shops with a large auditorium. It closed and was converted into a bingo hall in 1972. A local campaign was launched in 2023 to save the C-listed building from ruin after it has lain empty for seven years.

Always the same response: we’ll continue to engage with the owners. Report after report recommending the same. No action. But we’ll continue to engage.

Finally, the council actually did something. They served a dangerous buildings notice. The owners appealed. Sadly, the court ruled in their favour. From documents within the application to demolish, it appears the court ruled it was too little, too late.

Apparently, it considered the actions requested were not enough to save the building, therefore unjustifiable. How was a C-listed building allowed to get into this state?

This building has huge community backing alongside a dedicated team of local people. They’re skilled and experienced in architecture, design and running listed buildings as community facilities.

In our meeting with planning officials this week one resident asked what the point is in having listed buildings if there isn’t anything we can do to protect them. And it’s a question being asked across Scotland.

If people are allowed to own listed buildings, not maintain them and once they reach a state of disrepair, demolish them – what is the value of a listing?

Edinburgh Council will need to reflect on what it could have done differently. I’m also exploring what changes we could make to strengthen the law.

But there’s still hope for the George – no final decision has been made. The process must be transparent, decided by democratically elected councillors and with evidence about the condition of the building available publicly.

Residents can help by formally objecting to the demolition, making it clear just how much this building means to us all.

News you can trust since 1873
Follow us
© 2026 Iconic Media Group Ltd. All rights reserved.Cookie SettingsTerms and ConditionsPrivacy notice