Council faces the unforeseen effects of the Tourist Tax - Iain Whyte

Edinburgh Council is rarely lauded for successful policy implementation. So, you would think they would be familiar with economist Henry Hazlitt’s famous quote “that every action has unintended consequences”.

Hazlitt highlighted that government interventions or market regulations frequently trigger secondary effects unforeseen by the original decision-makers.

Tourists on the Royal Mile watching a Fringe performer.placeholder image
Tourists on the Royal Mile watching a Fringe performer. | Getty Images

For the Council things are even worse. The unintended consequences are often very visible and damaging. Councillors are regularly warned about them both in Council debates and from outside bodies.

The folly is that the broad spectrum of left-wing councillors in the City Chambers plough ahead regardless. Virtue signalling is seen as far more important than deliverable policy.

The latest example is the Tourist Tax which has been sold as a panacea for every ill. Yet the festivals who were expected to be amongst the beneficiaries have found themselves hugely out of pocket, paying the tax on accommodation for their performers.

This led to paralysis in the Chambers with a report on cultural grants and their relationship to Tourist Tax being pulled from Committee. There were so many different political views on the further tinkering needed to solve the festivals’ shortfall that no agreement was possible.

But the impossibly high costs of accommodation for Fringe performers is not a new story. And the International Festival and others told the Council in advance that an extra 5% Tax would add to their costs.

The Council answer seems to be that even more subsidy is required. But how do you do that fairly? Are some parts of the cultural sector to be given special treatment?

Should sporting bodies who bring athletes also be exempt? If superstar conductor Gustavo Dudamel doesn’t pay Tourist Tax should Robert Smith of The Cure?

Obviously, the audience must pay regardless.

The reaction of some councillors seemed to be that core Council grants should be dramatically and arbitrarily increased for the first time in ten years to cover the festivals’ shortfall. This worst of all solutions would have seen the Council Tax used rather than Tourist Tax income.

There will be many more unintended consequences from Tourist tax, not least with the plan to spend some on social housing restricted to tourism industry workers. How complex will the rules need to be to attempt fairness of allocation?

On Tourist tax, like so many things, the Council needs to heed consequences that are staring it in the face rather than learn lessons later.

News you can trust since 1873
Follow us
© 2026 Iconic Media Group Ltd. All rights reserved.Cookie SettingsTerms and ConditionsPrivacy notice