Demos are not the way to solve Westfield housing problems​​​​​​​ - Iain Whyte

If you like lurid headlines and hysteria, you’ll be forgiven for thinking that plucky demonstrators invading the Council Chambers this week prevented the bulldozers immediately reducing c to rubble against the wishes of owners.

The demonstrators, who caused security concerns for many councillors, were from Living Rent - a “tenants union”. But their ask this time was for private property owners, about half of whom are actually landlords.

Officials have recommended demolition of Westfield Courtplaceholder image
Officials have recommended demolition of Westfield Court

They claim to want repairs to the building instead of demolition but that will cost about £255k per flat. As they only sell for about £180k I don’t think the 62 owners will want to pay, even if they can.

The trouble for Living Rent is that if “the council” were to pay for this it can only come from rent. A full refurbishment would cost every other council tenant in the city about £1200 each plus financing costs when they are already complaining about 7 per cent rent rises.

Then you need a technical solution to problems of asbestos, leaking sewage pipes and crumbling concrete cladding. Sixteen contractors have declined the work and an industry source confirmed to me this week that the council officers are correct - the building is unfixable and should come down.

A solution might be to move out the few remaining council tenants and give the flats away to the other owners. But because the building will likely become dangerous if it deteriorates further the council would have to step in again and close it down.

What council officers suggested we offer owners (and their tenants) was to negotiate to purchase the flats, giving owners cash for something with a negative value, and moving residents to a council tenancy elsewhere with a very cheap rent that they might not normally qualify for.

Ultimately the massed left-wing councillors voted to delay and look at giving more freebies to private owners from other tenants’ money, being “kind” at other people’s expense while ignoring that owners have responsibilities as well as rights.

It reminded of the words of Adam Smith that “Virtue is more to be feared than vice, because its excesses are not subject to the regulation of conscience.”

Demolition? My judgement is it is inevitable, but it was never going to be soon. Now delayed at greater cost, the same uncomfortable choices will be before councillors and owners when the committee meets again in February.

Related topics:
News you can trust since 1873
Follow us
© 2026 Iconic Media Group Ltd. All rights reserved.Cookie SettingsTerms and ConditionsPrivacy notice