Donald Anderson: Safe as houses – why Edgelaw View is no ‘Tumbledown Terrace’
The temporary evacuation of a small number of homes at Edgelaw View in Gilmerton has understandably caused anxiety for those affected. Memories of the dramatic collapse at Ferniehill Terrace in 2000 remain vivid in the local community.
However, despite the similarities in location, the two situations are fundamentally different and there are good reasons why the risk to residents today is very low.


I’ve lived in Gilmerton most of my adult life and bought a house along the road from Edgelaw knowing full well the area had a long history of mineworkings. Indeed, I can see the old pithead site on my regular dog walks.
As council leader I was closely involved in the response to the Limestone Mines emergency. The issue was a major crisis in south Edinburgh and we were lucky to have some outstanding council officers and advisers to rely on in responding to the issue.
Council chief executive Tom Aitchison was well in his stride dealing with emergencies after helping tackle the catastrophic floods earlier that same year, and Mark Turley, then housing director was equally superb, as was the property team response led by Robin Adamson.
Housing officials including the office manager Jenny Brown were outstanding. Staff actually went into collapsing homes to rescue residents prized personal possessions.
The advice and support from engineers at Arup Scotland was faultless. I wish I could remember the name of the engineer who we arranged to speak at the public meetings – I should have kept a diary. He had the best communication skills I think I’ve seen in an emergency. His ability to convey complex issues in an understandable way was extraordinary.
The Limestone Mines collapse eventually led to the demolition of more than 200 homes. In their place, nearly 450 new homes were built at Hyvots and Fernieside and that’s created a much more attractive and vibrant neighbourhood.
There are two key differences between Limestone Mines and the issues at Edgelaw. First, Limestone Mines had chambers of up to 40 feet compared to four to ten feet in coal seams.
Second, they were very near the surface. And unlike coal mines, the Limestone Mines were largely undocumented.
The situation at Edgelaw View is of a different character. During site investigations, a previously unidentified historic mining feature was discovered beneath part of the development. Rather than waiting to see whether any problems emerged, Miller Homes is carrying out preventative engineering works. This is wise precautionary work, rather than an emergency.
That distinction is crucial. At Ferniehill, the ground had already begun to fail. At Edgelaw View, engineers identified a potential issue before any significant movement has occurred.
Modern construction standards, ground investigation techniques and engineering solutions are far more sophisticated than those available several decades ago. Boreholes, grouting and reinforced concrete are routinely used to stabilise old mine workings with a high degree of confidence.
Edinburgh has thousands of homes built over former mine workings. Most experience no problems throughout their lifetime because historic workings remain stable or have been successfully treated during development. They are, to use a well-worn phrase, ‘As safe as houses.’
It’s been a stressful time for the families, of that there is no doubt, but unlike the case of ‘Tumbledown Terrace’, residents should be back in their homes fairly soon.