Dr Arthur’s views on single sex spaces need to be challenged - Susand Dalgety
Just as the world is starting to recover from the gender cult that has infected large sections of society in recent years, up pops city MP, Dr Scott Arthur.
Twice in recent weeks, Dr Arthur – an Edinburgh councillor before he beat Joanna Cherry KC in the 2024 battle for the South West constituency – has shown his disregard for material reality.


First, he signed a motion which rejects the Equality and Human Rights Commission’s (EHRC) updated guidance on single sex facilities.
Last April, the Supreme Court, in a case brought by For Women Scotland, ruled that for the purposes of the Equality Act, sex is based on biology. The judgment confirmed what women campaigners had been saying all along, that single sex spaces, such as public toilets and changing rooms, are exactly what they say on the door – single sex.
Following the judgment, the EHRC provided parliament with updated guidance on how the law should be followed, but some MPs were not happy – including Dr Arthur. He told parliament that “this is not a settled issue” and suggested that the government might want to change the law, in effect to allow men who identify as women to use women’s single sex spaces.
Dr Arthur has clearly forgotten that he was elected only two years ago on the Labour Party’s manifesto that states quite clearly that it will support single-sex spaces. I suggest he goes back and reads it.
Then earlier this week, the good doctor was one of three Edinburgh MPs to vote in support of controversial plans to give children as young as 11 life-changing drugs that will delay their puberty. The theory behind this medical madness is that if a child who is confused about their sex is stopped from going through puberty for several years, the delay will give them more time to explore their feelings. The trouble is, research has shown that these drugs can have serious long-term side effects, including infertility and a significant reduction in bone density.
Worryingly, Dr Arthur’s stance was echoed in the City Chambers last Thursday when councillors voted to condemn the ECHR guidance and called on the UK government to reject it. A Scottish Greens motion, amended by the SNP and the Liberal Democrats, asserted that the guidance was discriminatory against trans people, unworkable and incompatible with human rights. It also called for the council to ensure that vital services which support survivors of domestic abuse and sexual violence remain inclusive – which is code for women’s refuges should be open to men who identify as women.
But perhaps the worst moment came when, during a deputation to the council, Zoe, a trans activist, described recent developments such as the EHRC guidance as a “genocide” against the trans community.
The Holocaust was genocide. Rwanda experienced a genocide in 1994, when up to a million people were slaughtered in 100 days. Asserting the law of the land, based on the reality of people’s biological sex, and arguing against vulnerable children being prescribed dangerous drugs, is not a genocide. It is common sense, and the sooner all our politicians accept that, the better it will be for society.