Edinburgh and Glasgow prove to be Scotland’s Oxbridge of the north - Donald Anderson

I’m in the invidious position of having to eat my words in the column this morning. A few weeks ago, I argued that Edinburgh’s success should be seen alongside the remarkable success of Manchester.

Alas, figures provided by urban economist Tom Forth have forced me to revise my view. Tom shared data from one of the most influential organisations the planet, the charity Our world in Data – a charity that employs arguably the most influential Edinburgh graduate and Scot in the world, Hannah Ritchie.

Hannah Ritchie is a Scottish data scientist, author, and Senior Researcher in the Programme for Global Development at the University of Oxford. Her academic background includes a BSc in Environmental Geoscience, an MSc in Carbon Management and a PhD in GeoSciences from the University of Edinburghplaceholder image
Hannah Ritchie is a Scottish data scientist, author, and Senior Researcher in the Programme for Global Development at the University of Oxford. Her academic background includes a BSc in Environmental Geoscience, an MSc in Carbon Management and a PhD in GeoSciences from the University of Edinburgh

In a world where the most important political question has become ‘What is the truth?’, Our World in Data is one of the most valuable resources in the world. A place where smart people there crunch the numbers on an astonishing array of issues. There’s information about almost anything you might want to know and it’s all been robustly fact checked.

Anyway, the figures quoted by Tom Forth showed that the Edinburgh city region outperformed the twin-engined powerhouse regions that contain Oxford and Cambridge. Since 1998, the city regions containing Oxford and Cambridge grew their economies 23 per cent and 34 per cent, while the Edinburgh city region growth measured 57 per cent.

Tom also quoted figures showing that the city regions of Edinburgh and Manchester showed almost exactly the same growth trajectory, with Edinburgh marginally ahead.

However, the region model used by Our World in Data isn’t based on the existing City Region Deal Partnership and includes Falkirk for some reason. What the figures show is that the Edinburgh City Region Growth outstrips Manchester, which means I was wrong. Edinburgh’s success isn’t comparable to Manchester’s it’s better.

That’s not the key lesson here, though. Any debate about growth in Scotland must include Glasgow. What Glasgow helps deliver – as is clear from these figures – is a knowledge-led growth corridor that gives Scotland an ‘Oxbridge of the north’.

While Glasgow faces many challenges – and we’re reading about all of them in the press of late - it is and has long been one of Britain’s most successful city economies.

We know that Edinburgh is the first major city in the UK to reach the landmark position of having 50 per cent of the population educated to degree level. Glasgow is also a leading knowledge city with its proportion of graduates not far behind Oxbridge. If you count the number of graduates in Oxford and Cambridge it comes to 140,000.

That’s an impressive figure, but added together Edinburgh and Glasgow’s total is almost three times that at around 400,000 degree educated residents.

Scotland’s future will increasingly depend on smart, successful cities. Everyone thinks that ‘Oxbridge’ perfectly represents that model, but we have our own ‘Oxbridge of the north’, which is a huge natural advantage for building an even stronger economy.

I started this article talking about Edinburgh, but as I have done many times, I’m drawn back to the view that for our small nation on the northern fringes of Europe, our people are our greatest asset. Edinburgh has outgrown and outcompeted Manchester and more than held its own against the powerhouse that is London.

As we face the challenges of an increasingly uncertain and fractious world we should look to build on our greatest strengths, and our greatest strengths are in Edinburgh and Glasgow, Scotland’s own ‘Oxbridge of the north.’

News you can trust since 1873
Follow us
© 2026 Iconic Media Group Ltd. All rights reserved.Cookie SettingsTerms and ConditionsPrivacy notice