Efficiency savings conundrum - Sue Webber
If there was some sort of plan behind Tuesday’s SNP budget, apart from not doing anything to lose more votes at May’s election, it was very hard to see what it was.
We were expected to be grateful that finance secretary Shona Robison was aping Labour spending decisions like school breakfast clubs when the money to do so would have come from an automatic increase in funding from Westminster.
And after years of being cut into the bone, colleges were supposed to be happy about a 10 per cent funding increase, while Dundee University’s reward for abject failure is a £20 million bail-out.
Local government is still being squeezed in real terms, so no wonder the free swimming lessons plan is only for this summer if half the nation’s pools are forced to close.
Much of the cash for giveaways will rely on a promise to deliver £1.5 billion in efficiency savings, and it was quite extraordinary for Ms Robison to accuse the Conservatives of not revealing more information behind a proposed £1 billion cost reduction plan when she had no details herself.
But don’t just take my word for it. Here’s what the Scottish Fiscal Commission had to say: “Underpinning the Spending Review are ambitious plans for efficiency savings and reducing the public sector workforce. If and how these plans are delivered will have implications for future public services and shape the fiscal context beyond May’s election.”
If and how? If the SFC doesn’t know, then no-one does. And by May it will be too late.