Homeless burden a problem in part of our own making - Iain Whyte
Opinion polls continue to show that immigration is a top three issue for the public. Yet you wouldn’t believe it if you listen to our Scottish political class who consistently make claims about being more welcoming than elsewhere in the UK.
One of the biggest examples is in housing. Here in Edinburgh the left-wing politicians who espouse increased migration and a welcome even if that’s migration by illegal means, also shout about a “Housing Emergency”.


Let me put this in context. We have over six thousand households in temporary homeless accommodation. About 1100 of those originated from outside the city. People are pulled in following a Scottish Government decision not to require a “local connection” when declaring yourself homeless.
This drags people to bigger cities from across Scotland but it also brings single young men who are not eligible for emergency housing in the rest of the UK. You might take a view that this is wrong but having a far more generous system without any safeguards and the funding to support it creates a pull factor for people to come to our city meaning unintended consequences.
The number of homeless cases from outside Edinburgh has grown by 287 per cent since April 2024. 71 per cent of those are asylum/refugee cases who are given leave to remain while elsewhere in the UK.
I don’t blame the migrants. If you came to the UK and had no money but were told you could stay, you’d look for housing. If you were then told you wouldn’t be housed where you were staying in England, it’s a perfectly natural reaction to come to Scotland where the authorities have to house you.
This matters because a chunk of our emergency accommodation is in unsuitable B&Bs which currently hold about 1000 households. It is also estimated that on 12 January we also had 89 individuals sleeping rough. This is almost exactly the number of homelessness cases from outside Edinburgh.
The Scottish Government is imposing a generous policy on the council but not helping with the financial burden. This imposes a tragic burden on some homeless individuals, both local and from further afield. They end up in unsuitable accommodation or worse sleeping rough.
Building housing takes time. But ignoring public concerns about housing, community safety and welfare largesse in the meantime only breeds resentment.
A first step would be for the Scottish Government to fund the council to meet the aspirations they set.