Leith and Newhaven should have been spared silence of the trams - Steve Cardownie
Hindsight is a wonderful thing but it is difficult to dismiss the points raised by chartered engineer, Iain Masterton, in yesterday’s Evening News, of what seems to be legitimate issues surrounding what he says is a lack of foresight by senior managers of our tram company.
Referring to the current partial closure of Princes Street due to the recent fire at the site of the former Debenham’s building, he states “For the last 12 years not one single manager, handsomely paid to run the system, even had the competence to imagine ‘I wonder what would happen if there is an incident that prevents trams corralled every night at Edinburgh Gateway from getting beyond a blockage?’ It never even crossed their minds - and even more negligent after the 2023 extension to Newhaven.”
All seems perfectly reasonable to me. He goes on to suggest that at least two tram sets should have been parked at the Newhaven end of the line which would have ensured that the city is not facing the problem it currently is, with Leith and Newhaven being temporarily severed from the system. I take the point that it is too late now, but what if a similar issue arises some time in the future?
The City of Edinburgh Council leader, Jane Meagher took to the pages of an earlier edition of this paper to appeal to readers to “get down to Leith and experience everything that is on offer there” and, as a Leither, I heartily concur.
The lack of tram transport down to the town, particularly during festival time when the city’s population doubles in size, is having an obvious impact on local business balance sheets, which they might take some time to recover from.
if I was a business owner in Leith, I would be asking the question - what if something similar happens again? This potential threat can and should be adequately catered for.
The lack of a sound contingency plan would only compound the original “oversight”- foresight, informed by hindsight, is what is required.
