Local government reform must start with a fairer council tax - Lorna Slater
Our local services do not simply appear. They depend on councils and the people who empty our bins, staff our libraries, care for older people, support children in schools and keep our streets clean and welcoming.
Yet the system that helps pay for those services is one of the least fair parts of our public finances.


On Wednesday, the Scottish Greens will bring a debate to Parliament and force a vote on a simple proposition:
If the Scottish Government is serious about reforming local government, it must commit to completely redesigning council taxes, as well as business rates.
The timing matters. Ministers are proposing a major shake-up of councils, which would see new regional and community authorities taking on different responsibilities.
There is a case for bringing decisions closer to people while ensuring services are being planned on the right scale. But changing the map without changing how our councils are funded risks giving communities a new structure and the same old problems.
Council tax is based on property values from April 1991. Thirty-five years later, those valuations bear little relation to today’s housing market.
The Institute for Fiscal Studies has highlighted how regressive the system is: in 1991, a Band H property was worth at least eight times a Band A home, yet its council tax charge is only 3.675 times higher. The tax, therefore, takes a smaller proportion of value from the most
expensive properties.
It asks too much of those with less, while giving the wealthiest a better deal.
This is not an obscure technical issue. Council tax helps fund schools, social care, libraries, leisure facilities and waste collection. When councils lack sustainable income, people see the consequences in reduced opening hours, stretched staff and services struggling to meet growing needs.
Nor is this demand being made in isolation. The Scottish Government’s own consultation found 82 per cent of respondents supported reform, while 67 per cent backed updating property valuations.
These were consultation responses, not a national opinion poll, and they are a clear signal that the status quo has run its course.
One alternative we could consider is a Residential Property Tax that is based on up-to-date property values. It must include relief for people on low or insecure incomes, and options to defer payment where someone is asset-rich but cash-poor.
This could be supported by regular revaluations no more than five years apart, and safeguards against widening regional inequalities. For rented homes, responsibility for payment should rest with the property owner, not the tenant.