Maybe the surveillance state was not such a bad idea after all - Susan Morrison
Scotland has pioneered many a great invention, but we really blazed a trail when it came to surveillance states. We could have shown the Stasi a thing or two.
We once led the world in How To Judge Your Neighbour. It was practically a commandment. In fact, in the hands of John Knox and the Reformation lads, it was. Now there’s a boy band to bring the mood down.


The boys of the Kirk had a wildly ambitious plan. They would create the most Godly nation on earth. To do that, everyone had to be vigilant that everybody was living according to the rules laid out in that massively detailed and frequently contradictory user guide, the King James Bible.
One less than committed member of the kirk and the entire nation was literally off to hell in a hand basket. Everyone in Scotland had the heaven-sent right to keep a godly eye on their neighbours, and bring any looming back sliding to the attention of the kirk sessions for a right old public ticking-off.
Examples of slipshod living could include sleeping in and missing Sunday services, side-eyeing the minister during a particularly lengthy sermon or selling your soul to Satan in return for all the riches of Araby, or at the very least, a cow.
The kirk was a haven for the women who watched. When I was a child, my granny took me to church, where she and Mrs McFadyen passed solemn judgement on all before them.
Those who failed to clean the stair, the lipstick-sporting Jezebels, and those damned souls rumoured to frequent public houses – all condemned as being ‘no better than they should be’. Still no idea what that means.
Even when the kirk lost some of its grip, Scotland still kept the habit of watch and yell. My childhood Glasgow had back courts, a brilliant playground for kids, especially if you had a big puddle to play in when the sewage pipe overflowed. Basically we were paddling in bacterial soup. How any of us made it to adulthood is a complete mystery.
Those kids were watched. Oh, how we were watched. The most terrifying sound of my childhood was that of a sash window flying up, closely followed by my name being bellowed. For a very long time I thought my full name was ‘Susan Morrison Stop That.’ Just to be clear, any woman had the right to shout at any child.
Of course, today’s world is far less judgemental. Shouting at random children is largely frowned up in polite society. And I’m starting to think that’s a bit of a shame. Perhaps we need to bring back a little judgement.
On a bus the other week two boys, probably not yet seven, ran riot. They fought, yelled and spat at each other, pushing past other passengers. At one point, the smaller of the two kicked his own mother. She didn’t flinch. Well, she was busy at the time. She was on the phone. Had I kicked my mother when I was six, I probably wouldn’t have seen seven.
No-one on the bus said anything. She’s not alone, of course. Few voices these days are raised to stop bad behaviour. No-one wants to look ‘judgy’.
Well, perhaps it's time to bring back a little of the firepower of the disapproving ladies of the kirk.
