Multiple versions of new releases not helping fans - Kevin Buckle
As I write this column the new Olivia Rodrigo album, You Seem Pretty Sad For A Girl So In Love, has yet to be announced as topping the charts, but I can say with some certainty that as you read this that will be the case.
The reason I am so sure is having seen the chart “sales” over the week. The last time I checked Olivia was 80,000 ahead of her nearest rival Michael Jackson, so was never going to be caught by any late surge.


I put sales in inverted commas, as while the chart for most of its life was based on sales, streaming is now converted into a theoretical sales figure and in the case of The Essential by Michael Jackson, virtually all the sales are simply people listening to him, which is not really what the chart was meant to be about
When I say virtually all the sales I am not exaggerating, with over 98 per cent of the sales figure not physical sales at all.
You can only imagine what the charts would have looked like in the old days, if based on what people were listening to as well as what they were going into shops to buy.
While a good chunk of the Olivia Rodrigo sales were not physical either, the majority still were and again even with physical sales we are living in different times.
There was a time when the number of versions of an album was little more than a record, a cassette and a compact disc. Sometimes there would be an extra more expensive CD with more tracks but really that was it.
The new Olivia Rodrigo album has ten different vinyl versions, three different CDs and confusingly two cassettes registering sales.
I say confusingly because her website offers three versions in baby blue, baby pink and hot pink. Maybe the pink sales have merged!
Certainly a cassette simply described as pink is the second best selling physical format after the standard compact disc, outselling any vinyl version.
If you are wondering how many of these versions you can go into a shop and buy the answer is three, being the option of a white or black vinyl and a CD. Most independent shops were given a poster they could give away but that was it.
Though over 200 independent record shops in the States opened at midnight to sell Olivia’s album with extra goodies to sell and give away, it was reported due to her love of independents, unfortunately that love didn’t stretch across the pond and HMV were given an exclusive vinyl and CD as well as an in-store only exclusive limited seven-inch.
Record companies will say they do all this to make sure their artist has a number one album but Olivia Rodrigo was guaranteed a chart topper whatever happened.
And while there is no harm in making the release more interesting, it is a shame that it is done by putting independent shops at a disadvantage and taking advantage of fans by persuading them to buy multiple copies of an album.
Maybe one day a major artist will have the guts to forego so many formats and not leave a sour taste in the mouth of the indies.