No surprise as Swinney returns, but can we just park indyref2? - Susan Dalgety

So it is all over bar the horse trading as to who gets what job in the new Scottish government.

The 2026 Holyrood elections proved to be a damp squib, with turnout down across most of the country and the result a foregone conclusion before the campaign even kicked off.

I still chuckle when I remember the daft call from the Scottish Green candidate Kate Nevens to abolish prisons.

Her party is now in a position of influence, so we can only hope John Swinney doesn’t listen to their more batty ideas. We must also hope that he stops blethering about independence and focuses on what really matters to the people of Scotland.

There is not going to be a referendum on whether Scotland should leave the UK any time soon. John Swinney may have promised a vote in 2028, but he had his fingers crossed behind his back when he made that particular pledge.

It was nothing more than a dog whistle to hardline nationalists. He knows that there is no appetite for another divisive referendum among the majority of the population. People are too concerned about the cost of living and the state of our public services to worry about the constitution.

If they had a choice between affordable housing for their kids and Holyrood to be in charge of its own army, my guess is they would plump for cheaper rents and mortgages for first time buyers.

Nor do people want cheap gimmicks like a free schoolbag and a few jotters for when their children start school.

Even if the SNP government fulfil this particular promise, a nylon backpack and a pencil case is not going to close the attainment gap between rich kids and those from poorer backgrounds.

And while we would all like to see supermarket prices drop, no-one, not even John Swinney himself, believes he can cap the cost of essential items such as bread and milk as he promised to do in his party’s manifesto. Holyrood cannot tell Aldi or Asda what to charge for their goods.

People want a government that works, whether it is in Holyrood or Westminster. They don’t need bribes, nor extravagant promises that can’t be kept.

They want a health service that provides excellent primary care, and responds quickly when they need more complex treatment. They want schools where their kids are safe and get taught the basics as well as the skills needed to navigate the 21st century. They want homes they can afford, social care for their older relatives, and a fair tax system.

They want their elected representatives to listen to them, not to dismiss their concerns as being ‘old-fashioned’ or worse. They want competent lawmakers, not show-offs.

Above all, they want a parliament that works for them, not a closed shop for mediocre politicians with daft ideas.

The new intake of MSPs will be sworn in later this week. They will swear or affirm an oath of allegiance to “His Majesty King Charles, his heirs and successors, according to law” – but their real promise must be to spend the next five years doing right by the people of Scotland.

News you can trust since 1873
Follow us
© 2026 Iconic Media Group Ltd. All rights reserved.Cookie SettingsTerms and ConditionsPrivacy notice