Pride in Place provokes democratic shame - Ed Thornley
What to do with £20 million? This was a question the Council had hoped it would need to answer when the UK Government announced its Pride in Place funding.
It was not to be. What emerged was another government decree, where five parts of the city were placed in competition. The sole element of the Council’s input? Filling in a questionnaire so the government could pick their winner.


This is not local decision-making, but it is a pattern that councils have been forced to get used to.
Difficult choices on shrinking budgets? Councils can do that. Investment and getting the credit? We’ll keep that for ourselves, and you’ll thank us for it.
It’s also resulted in the unedifying sight of Edinburgh’s Labour MPs scrabbling between themselves to get that credit, in the full knowledge that only one will ever have anything to show for it.
Of course, investment is welcome. I have spent far too much time arguing for governments to fund councils better. To say otherwise would be hypocritical politics.
Which brings me to the piece by the Council’s SNP leader last week.
Councillor Kumar knows that the SNP Scottish Government – which she hopes to join next year – is equally guilty of this kind of nonsense.
To lambast the UK Government, implying that the SNP are champions of local decision- making, or have anything other than the most centralising record of any Scottish Government, is laughable.
Between Police Scotland, the failed attempts at a National Care Service and ringfenced council funding, the SNP has no leg to stand on here.
So yes, let’s call out Pride in Place for what it is – another refusal to allow real local decision- making – but let’s not sit on our high horse and pretend that this isn’t something of which all government parties are guilty.