Promotion requires obvious display of failure - Jo Mowat

To many Councillors, the Governance, Risk and Best Value Committee (GRBV) is the last place they want to be and Internal Audit reports presented to GRBV are the last documents they want to read.

But those reports often shine a light on murkier areas of council activity. At last Thursday’s GRBV, the Committee room was lit up by an audit report.

The council is drawing up a best practice guide on Houses in Multiple Occupation (HMOs), to help improve standards in the sectorplaceholder image
The council is drawing up a best practice guide on Houses in Multiple Occupation (HMOs), to help improve standards in the sector

For a long time, Edinburgh has illegally housed homeless people in unlicensed Houses in Multiple Occupation (HMOs). The Covid-19 pandemic accelerated their use. However, it is clear that little, or no, action was taken to ensure property owners obtained the appropriate licences. The council’s directors started discussing the issue in late 2021 but amazingly no director thought it appropriate to discuss the matter with councillors.

In September 2022 an obscure reference in a confidential report to the Housing, Homeless and Fair Work Committee (HHFW) gave the first indication something was wrong. The Council’s Directors in November 2022 recognised the problem and the illegality was to be notified to the Group Leaders. That briefing was dated, but never presented. The audit report tells us that “officers were unable to provide a rationale for why the draft briefing was not shared.”

Each Council Director produces a very boring document each year called an Assurance Statement. In 2022 and 2023, the Place Director, now the Council Chief Executive, completed there was partial compliance with legislation, but forgot to mention the specifics of the HMO illegality.

As far as Committee can tell, in March 2023, the HHFW Convenor, Jane Meagher, now the Council leader, was briefed by the new Service Director about the illegality, but she and the Council Directors did not think to tell the former Council leader, who only found out in August 2024.

As with the Tour de France debacle, Councillors have been kept in the dark. It is time for the Council’s administrative leadership to display the transparency they often talk about. One thing is clear about this latest council shambles, whatever the role, promotion requires an obvious display of failure.

News you can trust since 1873
Follow us
© 2026 Iconic Media Group Ltd. All rights reserved.Cookie SettingsTerms and ConditionsPrivacy notice