Record sales and marketing strategy needs a big rethink - Kevin Buckle

I was in London last week meeting record companies, labels and the Entertainment Retail Association, who among many other things organise Record Store Day. There was no particular agenda with most people just keen to know how our new, bigger Avalanche shop was working out.

Unusually for a shop we aren’t interested in trying to get exclusives so we can steal a march on others with new releases and instead are happy to rely on our reputation and location, so I wasn’t there to try to strike any deals that way. There was, however, one idea running through virtually all the meetings and that was how important week one sales are considered to be.

Avalanche Records owner Kevin Buckle at the new, larger store, still within Waverley Marketplaceholder image
Avalanche Records owner Kevin Buckle at the new, larger store, still within Waverley Market

Of course, sales in the first week of an album have always been important, but mainly as a launchpad for further sales. These days it appears once a label and artist have their soundbite about their chart place for their publicity, they are not overly concerned about the sales that follow, which amazed me.

I have access to the sales figures, so I was well aware of just how poor even week two sales can be, never mind sales a couple of months down the line.

Trying to get all of an artist’s fans to preorder an album so sales show up on day one is one thing, but then there seems to be little thought as how to keep that momentum going.

One way that sales have continued in a shop in previous years is by those shops being supportive over the weeks that follow. But these days the shops that labels focus on to get their early sales are promoting a new album the next week, so the previous week’s album is history.

Labels and artists seem happy with a chart placing even if they know the figures are quite low and never is this more relevant than in the Scottish chart, where figures don’t even need to reach three figures to get a decent placing.

All involved now seem happy to sacrifice sales numbers and longevity of sales just so they can put the best possible spin on things in the media and get more traction with streaming companies.

Word had spread, it transpired, about just how good the new shop looks and the kind of footfall we get, especially after we had a couple of visits from record companies and I have agreed to work with them more.

In-stores are a problem, as I have always wanted people to be able to come and see a band without making them buy the album. This worked perfectly in both our Cockburn Street and Grassmarket shops where bands like Idlewild and The Twilight Sad would play and rack up over a hundred sales.

But as time went on, the majority of people who came had already bought the album directly from the band online. We could offer ticket only sales I’m told, but again I would rather the in-stores were free.

I did tell some pretty important people that their sales and marketing strategy was completely wrong and given the opportunity I could show them that, so we will see how that pans out in the future.

Related topics:
News you can trust since 1873
Follow us
© 2026 Iconic Media Group Ltd. All rights reserved.Cookie SettingsTerms and ConditionsPrivacy notice