Results mean more than election promises - Ed Thornley

Last month, a Freedom of Information request revealed the number of new pieces of casework each of Edinburgh’s 63 councillors had opened on behalf of their constituents from March 2025 to March 2026.

Each of those cases represents something done on behalf of a resident, a new issue raised, a new argument taken up. You can see the results of the FOI on the Council’s website disclosure log, it makes an interesting read.

Ed Thornley, Councillor for Drum Brae/Gyle and Leader of the Liberal Democrat groupplaceholder image
Ed Thornley, Councillor for Drum Brae/Gyle and Leader of the Liberal Democrat group

The top third of councillors, by number of new cases, is dominated by the Liberal Democrats. The bottom ten contains only the SNP and Greens.

As we approach the Holyrood election, a number of Edinburgh councillors will be on ballot papers on 7 May, seeking a seat in the Scottish Parliament. Of them, four are in that bottom ten on the list.

There are some councillors who clearly view the Council Chamber as their training arena for bigger things. There are some who rise to deliver soaring oratory to expound their own party’s virtues or excoriate others.

Then there are those who are there to work, who focus on their wards, on delivering for their residents. They may speak less in the Chamber, but their work rate is clear through committees and casework.

Now, I accept that those characterisations cut across all parties, and there are plenty who fall between the two. No-one is completely immune to a bit of political point-scoring – yet it cannot be denied that in some parties the balance skews heavily one way or the other.

My residents tell me they want things done. They want representatives who beat the drum for their wards, who focus on making change and delivering for their constituents.

There is little appetite these days for MSPs who simply grandstand. Many people feel that the last term of the Scottish Parliament has been full of consultation and review, with no progress on the real issues. People tell me that politicians should get their heads down and actually deliver.

With that in mind, my plea as postal votes begin to be returned, is that we all consider whether it’s time to look at the proof in front of us. That we ask who works hard for their residents, and say “Yes. I want an MSP who’s proven they will work hard,” rather than promising yet more grand visions, which sadly will go undelivered.

News you can trust since 1873
Follow us
© 2026 Iconic Media Group Ltd. All rights reserved.Cookie SettingsTerms and ConditionsPrivacy notice