Road improvements are a good thing but why take so long? - Iain Whyte
With the council any good news always seems to be accompanied by some bad. At a minimum there’s a caveat that means the good isn’t quite what it should be.
Our roads and pavements are thought of as being “like in a third world country” by most residents, so I was delighted when I was told that Restalrig Road was to be resurfaced.


It is one of the worst surfaces in the city, so it is great that the whole length between Leith Links and the Restalrig roundabout is being done, with some much-needed pavement and drainage improvements thrown in.
So, what’s the caveat? The time taken to do the job of course.
Work started in early March at the Leith Links end, but it isn’t expected to finish until the end of July. The worst section, which is in part of my Craigentinny/Duddingston Ward south of Alemoor Park, won’t properly begin until June.
In the meantime, there are huge bus diversions as each short section requires a full road closure. For the number 34 heading to Ocean Terminal this is particularly circuitous and misses out whole swathes of people for whom that is their only bus.
When you see the work in action the expected timescale isn’t a surprise. By last Friday the old surface had been removed in the first section. Yet, by the middle of the week there was no sign of anything new being laid at the foot of Restalrig Road.
Contrast this with work I saw in London some years ago on a similarly busy bus route. Here the closures were overnight only.
Each section was about 50m long and they used a machine that scraped off the old surface at the front and laid the new at the back as it went along.
With work done in short sections the road remained open in the daytime and traffic, including vital buses, still flowed.
There may be reasons why it takes a bit longer. Maybe work is needed to repair the subsurface making it more complex than what I saw in London. But I can’t believe there aren’t quicker ways of doing the work.
A road closure in stages for almost half the year, affecting up to three major bus routes takes disruption to a whole new level.
It had better be a super smooth surface when it’s finished to make it worthwhile.