Sad end to Richard Murphy Architects after 35 years - Kevin Buckle

It was sad to hear that the award-winning Scottish practice Richard Murphy Architects is being wound up after 35 years of trading, blaming the ‘box-ticking’ public procurement system and a lack of competition wins.

The news was regularly linked with their involvement in the redevelopment of the Old Royal High School and they were, of course, replaced on that project earlier this year by Reiach and Hall as the architectural partner for the construction phase of the Old Royal High School.

A drawing by Richard Murphy Architects of the gardens and Calton Hill at Highnote, Scotland's National Centre for Musicplaceholder image
A drawing by Richard Murphy Architects of the gardens and Calton Hill at Highnote, Scotland's National Centre for Music

Highnote is the recently unveiled brand identity for Scotland's National Centre for Music, a £77m project transforming Edinburgh's long-vacant Old Royal High School on Calton Hill into a national music hub.

The project is said to be on track and set to finish in spring 2028 ahead of a summer 2028 public opening though many have their doubts.

If all goes to plan there will be three main performance spaces (including a main hall with a specialist moving floor), alongside dedicated practice rooms and a recording studio. In addition there will be a new café, bar, conference and events facilities, offices and an expanded lower-ground foyer.

The surrounding two acres of ground will be redesigned by landscape architect Tom Stuart-Smith into accessible public gardens with panoramic city views.

All of this information comes from the blurb provided by the developers of the Old Royal High School and, of course, it is one thing saying all this stuff and another carrying it out successfully.

The enabling works have been completed, so in theory there should be no unpleasant surprises when the construction work starts but there have always been doubts about carrying out works on such an important building sitting on volcanic rock which is never easy to work with. There are a lot of people who will be surprised if the project now continues smoothly without a few more twists and turns.

There was even more bad news when the plans for a major revamp of Princes Street and the Waverley Valley put forward by Richard Murphy Architects were thrown out by Edinburgh Council in September and instead a ‘pragmatic’ alternative backed by council officers was chosen.

I’m not sure what brief had been given for the project but it was accused of being too ambitious and certainly it was a surprise that council officials even put the plans forward given they were not priced or given a timescale for completion.

The lesson that can be learned I think from both the Old Royal High School and the Princes Street and Waverley Strategy is that these days money is tight on virtually all projects architects are given to look at, with building costs having risen considerably since the pandemic and there maybe is no longer a place for an architects practice like Richard Murphy.

The exception to the need to watch the pennies has been the revamp of the Jenners building where it would appear money is no object, but even then it has faced other issues and is not currently expected to be open to the public until 2029.

That project spans 12 floors and includes retail, hospitality, cultural spaces, a 96-room hotel, and a publicly accessible Grand Saloon but many still think it will open its doors before Highnote.

Related topics:
News you can trust since 1873
Follow us
© 2026 Iconic Media Group Ltd. All rights reserved.Cookie SettingsTerms and ConditionsPrivacy notice