Sarwar is on the side of Scots but are Scots on Sarwar’s side? - Susan Dalgety

My heart breaks for Scottish Labour leader Anas Sarwar. His decision to call for the Prime Minister to quit could not have been an easy one to reach.

The Labour Party has always been riven with factions, but there is a comradeship that binds its members together – at least publicly – a code that Sarwar broke last Tuesday when he told a press conference that the leadership in Downing Street “has to change”.

Sarwar’s call for Starmer to go has been described by many as courageous. And indeed it took guts to say out loud what almost every MP, MSP, councillor and party activist has been saying on WhatsApp for the past 18 months: that Keir Stamer is simply not up to the job of leading the country. But Anas Sarwar didn’t have a choice. His courage is born of desperation.

Scottish Labour has plunged in the polls since the general election in July 2024, and is now sitting at only around 18 per cent, third behind Reform and the SNP. Something drastic had to happen if Sarwar was to have any chance of realising his ambition of becoming First Minister.

His gamble may pay off. By putting clear red water between him and Keir Starmer, he is sending a strong message that he is his own man, that he is leader of Scottish Labour, not the manager of a branch office of UK Labour. He put his country before his party.

I am sure he would have been happier if some of the MPs, including cabinet ministers, who agree with his analysis had come out in support, but as a seasoned politician he will be used to his comrades saying one thing to his face while briefing the complete opposite to others, including the press.

What his intervention last week showed is that Sarwar has what it takes to be First Minister. He is ready to make tough decisions. To tell people the truth. And to stand up for Scotland, even if it means upsetting his friends and colleagues in Westminster. He has put himself firmly on the side of the majority of Scots who say Starmer is doing a bad job. Question is: will they be on Sarwar’s side come May 7?

News you can trust since 1873
Follow us
© 2026 Iconic Media Group Ltd. All rights reserved.Cookie SettingsTerms and ConditionsPrivacy notice