Scotland’s government by announcement - Ian Murray

In Scotland today, 38,674 adults and 15,046 children are homeless, rough sleeping is at its highest level in 14 years and the number of people in temporary accommodation is at a record high.

But in the Scottish Budget published last week, the SNP imposed real-terms cuts to key initiatives which help councils prevent homelessness.

Finance Secretary Shona Robison’s Budget failed the homeless (Picture: Jeff J Mitchell)placeholder image
Finance Secretary Shona Robison’s Budget failed the homeless (Picture: Jeff J Mitchell)

In 2024, the Scottish Government declared a national housing emergency; is it any wonder this continues unabated when the SNP are choosing to cut funding to homelessness prevention?

Turning to another massive challenge confronting Scotland: drug and alcohol deaths. Scotland is the drug deaths capital of Europe, and lives continue to be ruined and lost by this awful issue, yet the SNP are inflicting a real-terms funding cut of about £1.3m in this crucial policy area.

The grim truth is that seven years after the SNP declared a drug deaths emergency, people are still dying, families are still grieving and a generation has been failed.

Meanwhile, the Scottish Budget offers no solutions to the issues leading to billions of pounds of taxpayers’ money being wasted. There’s still no meaningful plan to tackle delayed discharge, which costs the taxpayer half a billion, and causes stress and anxiety for those individuals and families affected. We’ve seen 130 major health strategies announced since 2007; that’s one every seven weeks.

What links the above issues? A tendency to make big, bold announcements and then do absolutely nothing to follow them up. Whether it’s declaring a housing emergency, a drug deaths emergency or unveiling yet another health strategy, the Scottish Government make a big splash... and then seem to do nothing.

It’s government by announcement. But this is not enough to tackle some of the major challenges facing Scotland, challenges which have grown in scope and scale over the last almost 20 years of the SNP.

And there are concerning reports that decisions made in the Budget will leave community organisations in Edinburgh facing funding cuts, including groups based in Edinburgh South.

Community organisations are a vital source of support for people in the most vulnerable and deprived parts of the city, but reports suggest that they will be hit with a £3m cut. I will be contacting the groups affected in my constituency to see what I can do to support them.

All of this comes despite the vastly increased resources available to the Scottish Government thanks to the hard work of Scottish Labour MPs on the government benches in Westminster.

The Labour government has provided the Scottish Government with an additional £10.3bn in funding since coming to power. Inexplicably, SNP MPs at Westminster voted against that extra money.

It gave the Scottish Government an enormous opportunity - to tackle waiting lists and close the education attainment gap between schools in the most and least deprived areas. But, tragically, they have wasted that opportunity.

After almost 20 years in power, can anyone really say that the SNP has the energy, ambition or ideas to tackle some of the huge challenges facing Scotland? If they had the ideas, they’d have implemented them by now.

This is the SNP’s 19th budget, and it won’t change Scotland for the better. The election on 7 May is our chance for a new direction with Scottish Labour.

News you can trust since 1873
Follow us
© 2026 Iconic Media Group Ltd. All rights reserved.Cookie SettingsTerms and ConditionsPrivacy notice