Steve Cardownie: Tram plans look good on paper but where is the money coming from?
Last week this paper revealed that the Edinburgh City Council’s SNP group had come out against a proposal to extend the city’s tramline to Granton.
Two potential routes are currently under review but both are mired in controversy, so the SNP group spotted the opportunity to “steal a march” on their opponents this side of the Scottish Parliamentary election by declaring that they were not in favour of either route.


The routes being considered are either going down the “Roseburn Path” or alternatively going across the Dean Bridge. The Liberal Democrats on the council have already said that they will not support the Roseburn Path option and neither will the Greens, so given the SNP’s new position, that would appear to be a non-starter (more of that later.)
The SNP group said that work should start first on the southern section of the line (between the city centre and Edinburgh Royal Infirmary) and that council officials should find another route from the city centre to Granton.
So, just like pulling a rabbit from a hat, council officials are expected to magic up a new route to Granton and start the whole process again - a proposal which has attracted the expected level of scorn from some opposition councillors.
The city’s Transport Convener, Cllr Stephen Jenkinson, is seething about this move, stating that it is “premature” and “reckless” and that it jeopardised the whole tram extension project as the SNP group have taken this stance before the public consultation results have been published and before the strategic business case is due to be presented in September.
This is the same Stephen Jenkinson who issued a statement last November (when referring to the route over the Dean Bridge) saying that “while this option is still on the table, the undeniable facts are that it is calculated to cost hundreds of millions more than the Roseburn Path and ultimately carry fewer passengers – with the added complication of having to undertake significant work on a Category A listed structure in the Dean Bridge.”
Nothing “premature” or “reckless” about nailing your colours to the mast then Stephen?
Figures released under a freedom of information request last October revealed that £1,117,496 of council dosh had already been spent up till then on the project labelled “Trams from Granton to Edinburgh BioQuarter/ Royal Infirmary of Edinburgh and beyond”, most of which (£1,086,000) was spent on external consultants - not bad for a council that is strapped for cash!
The projected cost of a north-south tram extension is estimated to fall between £2 billion and £2.9 billion, depending on which route is chosen. The estimated cost of developing a full business case is around £44 million.
As yet, no one has identified where the money to build any extension is to come from. The Scottish Government has refused to get involved and the council administration has said that it will not contribute any council cash to the project – what about the money already spent?
The City Council Conservative group Leader, Cllr Iain Whyte, hit the nail squarely on the head when he said “Neither government has come up with any money; the council doesn’t have any money – we’re borrowed up to the eyeballs….until you get some kind of guarantee of funding, the whole thing is fantasy.”
